Are Stans the internet’s most toxic subculture?

Fear of the fandom — From Beyonce’s Beyhive to Rihanna’s Navy: the world of online fandom has become both impressive and extreme. Is it time we took its power more seriously?

A few years ago, I wrote a piece about a pop star. I criticised aspects of her persona and what she tended to sing about, and I suggested that to grow up and mature as a musician she should abandon her feuds and delve deeper into the complexities of adulthood. I was proud of the piece and stood by what I wrote, but knew that I would likely be privy to a little bit of pushback. And then came the Stans.

For anyone who’s found themselves on the receiving end of a fanbase’s fury, you know that there are few experiences like it. For 24-48 hours, you are subjected to a tidal wave of insults and Emojis. In my case, an abundance of snakes appeared on my Instagram photos – a move outshined only by the flood of zero-star Goodreads reviews my book received months before it even came out. 

Blossoming from the infamous titular character of the 2000 Eminem song, ‘Stans’ are fans who take it to the extreme. Chat rooms, blogs, and social media have helped them wield their numbers and online diligence to ensure that artists they love will never be subjected to undue shade or even valid criticism. And while such power is awe-inspiring in its magnitude, it is also a colossal buzzkill if you’re just a person on the internet weighing in on new the Beyonce (Beyhive), Rihanna (The Navy), Ariana (Arianators), or T-Swift (Swifties). 

Of course, it’s easy for me to say that fan armies are taking their adulation too far. As a 34-year-old writer and person, I’m capable of putting my feelings in a jar and forgetting that when I lived for the Spice Girls or Leonardo DiCaprio (a complicated issue I have yet to resolve), I would’ve physically fought anybody who didn’t feel exactly the same way. At age 12, the Spice Girls epitomised the greatness of what can happen when women lean into aspects of their most extreme selves. And at 13, I believed in my soul that whatever cinematic choices Leo made were serving as stepping stones to us finally being together. 

To dismiss these experiences would be a mistake. To be a fan who ardently adores an artist isn’t just an important part in trying to understand your feelings: it helps form a type of kinship that can make you feel less alone. When somebody’s work gives you power you didn’t know you were capable of, or taps into a part of yourself you didn’t know existed, of course you will want to rush to their defence.

But that’s the thing about fan culture today. Now, thanks to the internet, communities can mobilise effortlessly. And while that’s an incredible thing to watch in action, it’s less incredible to be on the receiving end of it. Particularly when artists know what their fan bases are capable of, and still drag writers, strangers or critics who give them negative reviews. Last week, Lana del Ray responded to critic Ann Powers’ review of Norman Fucking Rockwell! on Twitter, and Lizzo did the same back in April in response to Pitchfork’s less-than-amazing album rating.

Here’s a little sidenote on your piece – I don’t even relate to one observation you made about the music. There’s nothing uncooked about me. To write about me is nothing like it is to be with me. Never had a persona. Never needed one. Never will.

— Lana Del Rey (@LanaDelRey) September 5, 2019

On some level, this defensiveness makes sense: who wouldn’t want to step up to defend our work against someone who couldn’t see the blood, sweat, and tears that went into it? But there are incidences that are less justifiable. When Morgan Stewart claimed Justin Bieber was lip-syncing during a surprise Coachella performance in April, not only did Justin respond to him on Twitter, Ariana Grande jumped in to stoke the fire. Predictably, the Stans of both armies jumped in to send Stewart abuse. In that moment, it wasn’t a question of participating in discourse – it was actually irresponsible.

Art is a matter of interpretation in which we, as listeners, form our own thoughts and feelings, and congregate together to form fanbases that may have strong opinions or means of defence. But we need to remember that criticism is art too: it helps us shape our own critical thinking skills, and holds us all to higher standards. Ultimately, criticism isn’t trolling: it dares us to think harder and create better.

Which means that the Stans who relish in dragging those with opposing tastes may not be actual fans at all. Real fans, while wanting to ruin somebody’s life over a disagreement about an artist’s trajectory, tend not to pepper their enemy’s Instagram page with certain Emojis. Nor do they clap back by means of exponential RT-ing, urging others to do the same. Fans attend shows, they buy albums, they find each other, they wear merch. Yes they are passionate, and yes, they champion the artists they love – but few tend to demonise anyone who doesn’t feel the same way they do in ways that make them need to abandon Twitter for a few days. Fans, for the most part, are people who love a thing. And I like to think that artists know this, even when it seems like they’re soliciting the muscle of those who use their love of said thing as an excuse to ruin a stranger.

Stans have a lot of power now, which is why I fear them. And I fear that when artists enable them, they forget that they’re stoking not a fanbase, but a living and breathing excuse to assert one’s power for no reason other than because they can. 

Fans, however? I am one. Most of us are. And to that end, we know that fandom needn’t always exist in extremes, particularly since even with the elevation of the internet, we know there’s still enough room to love and hate someone (or something) without anyone being digitally drawn and quartered. Because passion is never a bad thing – until it justifies whatever bad thing you’d like to do.

Follow Anne T. Donahue on Twitter.

Enjoyed this article? Like Huck on Facebook or follow us on Twitter.


Ad

Latest on Huck

Red shop frontage with "Open Out" branding and appointment-only signage.
Activism

Meet the trans-led hairdressers providing London with gender-affirming trims

Open Out — Since being founded in 2011, the Hoxton salon has become a crucial space the city’s LGBTQ+ community. Hannah Bentley caught up with co-founder Greygory Vass to hear about its growth, breaking down barbering binaries, and the recent Supreme Court ruling.

Written by: Hannah Bentley

Cyclists racing past Palestinian flag, yellow barriers, and spectators.
Sport

Gazan amputees secure Para-Cycling World Championships qualification

Gaza Sunbirds — Alaa al-Dali and Mohamed Asfour earned Palestine’s first-ever top-20 finish at the Para-Cycling World Cup in Belgium over the weekend.

Written by: Isaac Muk

Crowded festival site with tents, stalls and an illuminated red double-decker bus. Groups of people, including children, milling about on the muddy ground.
© Alan Tash Lodge
Music

New documentary revisits the radical history of UK free rave culture

Free Party: A Folk History — Directed by Aaron Trinder, it features first-hand stories from key crews including DiY, Spiral Tribe, Bedlam and Circus Warp, with public streaming available from May 30.

Written by: Isaac Muk

Weathered wooden building with a tall spire, person on horseback in foreground.
Culture

Rahim Fortune’s dreamlike vision of the Black American South

Reflections — In the Texas native’s debut solo show, he weaves familial history and documentary photography to challenge the region’s visual tropes.

Written by: Miss Rosen

A collage depicting a giant flup for mankind, with an image of the Earth surrounded by planets and people in sci-fi costumes.
Culture

Why Katy Perry’s space flight was one giant flop for mankind

Galactic girlbossing — In a widely-panned, 11-minute trip to the edge of the earth’s atmosphere, the ‘Women’s World’ singer joined an all-female space crew in an expensive vanity advert for Jeff Bezos’ Blue Origin. Newsletter columnist Emma Garland explains its apocalypse indicating signs.

Written by: Emma Garland

Three orange book covers with the title "Foreign Fruit" against a dark background.
Culture

Katie Goh: “I want people to engage with the politics of oranges”

Foreign Fruit — In her new book, the Edinburgh-based writer traces her personal history through the citrus fruit’s global spread, from a village in China to Californian groves. Angela Hui caught up with her to find out more.

Written by: Katie Goh

Huck is supported by our readers, subscribers and Club Huck members. It is also made possible by sponsorship from:

Signup to our newsletter

Sign up to our newsletter to informed with the cutting edge of sport, music and counterculture, featuring personal takes on the state of media and pop culture from Emma Garland, former Digital Editor of Huck, exclusive interviews, recommendations and more.

Please wait...

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.