Diversity at Victoria’s Secret: does it really matter?

Here we go again — Earlier this week, Victoria’s Secret came under fire for dismissing the inclusion of plus-size and transgender models in their shows. Personal trainer and writer Ban Hass probes why so many people – both in the fitness world and out – are still so oblivious to the power of their own privilege.

Last week, the annual Victoria’s Secret Fashion Show – one of the most-watched, lavish fashion events of the year came to New York for its 23rd edition. But with its unattainable beauty standards and unrealistic body ideals, we have to wonder: why is anyone still watching it? Why are we applauding and celebrating women prancing around in their underwear in 2018? Are tiaras empowering? Are wings really inspiring?

The brand came under fire on social media last week after Victoria’s Secret Chief Marketing Officer Ed Razek announced in an interview with Vogue that the brand didn’t want plus-size or transgender models walking on the runway because “the show is a fantasy”. Despite sales falling over the last few years, Razek continued to defend their decision by explaining that they “don’t market to the whole world.” (He has since issued an apology, saying that his comments were “insensitive.”)

Predictably, the reaction was strong. Victoria’s Secret was slammed. Tess Holliday called on her 1.7 million Instagram followers to boycott the lingerie brand. American model, actress and fashion designer, Isis King, didn’t hold back either, telling Twitter she could no longer support the brand, despite previously being a loyal customer. (King was the first trans woman to compete on America’s Next Top Model.)  

At first, I wasn’t really bothered either. I’ve never really been bothered. As a personal trainer – someone who professionally makes people feel good about their bodies – I’ve never considered the Victoria’s Secret show problematic, or controversial. Don’t like it? Don’t watch it. Truth be told, those ridiculously gorgeous women don’t inspire me to work out harder. Their toned legs and taut mid-sections don’t make me want to cut out cheese. Put simply, I’m pretty unaffected by the Victoria’s Secret Fashion show.

But why don’t tall, skinny, superhuman good-looking women prancing around in diamonds and glitter make me feel bad? Why shouldn’t it bother me that, in 2018, when every other brand is updating their business to reflect how far we have come with the body positivity movement, Victoria’s Secret arrogantly refuses to diversify?

It’s not just because I am a strong, powerful woman who understands that physical beauty is not enough. It’s not just because I’m kind, caring and, above all, completely hilarious. It’s not just because I believe women are so much more than their bodies.

It’s because I can’t relate. I’m a cisgender woman with a socially acceptable body shape, so I’m not an outsider. Sure, I may be Middle Eastern, and I don’t look like Sara Sampaio but my size is still widely represented.

If you can’t understand why Ed Razek’s comments are offensive, it’s probably because you have privilege. If you fail to see why Victoria’s Secret need to change their narrative, why they need to include plus-sized and transgender models in their catwalk, it’s likely that you are in a position of power.

You don’t need to look like Adriana Lima to have ‘thin privilege’. If you’re shaking your head, because you hate your belly pooch and your moon face, understand that body confidence issues have nothing to do with advantage. You can have thin privilege without feeling thin. It’s about being able to walk down the street without worrying about someone hurling abuse at you, or walking into a store without wondering whether they will stock your size or not. Thin privilege is eating what you want without feeling judged.

Cisgender privilege is real too. According to research published by YouGov and LGBT charity Stonewall, in the UK, one in eight transgender employees have been physically attacked by a colleague or customer in the last year. If you have the ability to generally ‘blend in’ and not be constantly stared at, pointed at, or gawked at, you have cisgender privilege. If your identity is not considered a mental pathology, you have an advantage.

No non-cisgender women were invited to attend the Victoria’s Secret Fashion Show castings this year. In 23 years, the brand has failed to cast a single plus-sized model, despite the fact that the average woman is a size 16-18. Why? Because tall, pretty, cisgender, and skinny is the “fantasy”. A fantasy created by a straight man. Although ‘real’ women may watch these shows and purchase the lingerie, this only stems from a deep-rooted belief that they need to look like an Angel in order to be desired. This isn’t our fantasy. It’s theirs. And this is how it’s always been throughout history.

In my world, fantasy isn’t starvation (the models have publicly spoken about the restrictive diet they are put under leading up to the show). Fantasy isn’t dehydration (Adriana Lima told the press she stopped drinking 12 hours before the show to ‘dry out’). Fantasy isn’t a woman being told she’s not thin enough to appear on stage (Erin Heatherton stopped working with the brand after four years of pressure to lose more weight). For a brand that attempts to sell  ‘female empowerment’  Victoria’s Secret needs to do better.

Empowering is allowing transgender women to walk the runway. Empowering is showing a diversity of body types. And it’s not just plus sized women and transgender woman that need to be represented. What about models with disabilities? Or models with dwarfism?

If you want to empower people, you need to make them feel accepted, represented and welcome in a space where they have been historically excluded. And while Victoria’s Secret may have missed the memo, Aerie (the brand’s biggest rival in the US) launched a campaign earlier this summer featuring models with a wide range of disabilities. The campaign was met with an overwhelmingly positive response, proving that diversity and inclusion is key to success.

But it’s not just Victoria’s Secret that needs to do better. We need to do better. Until they change their narrative, we need to stop watching the show. We need to stop buying their bras and their overpriced floral body mists. We need to stop endorsing a brand that’s outdated. And above all, if we don’t understand ‘the fuss,’ we need to take a step back and educate ourselves, and realise how fortunate we are.

Ban Hass is a personal trainer and writer from London. Follow her on Twitter and Instagram.

Enjoyed this article? Like Huck on Facebook or follow us on Twitter.


Ad

Latest on Huck

A punk rock band performing on stage, with a female lead singer belting into a microphone. Behind them, a colourful mural with graffiti-style text.
Music

Meet the hair-raised radical women of Berlin’s noise punk scene

Powertool — In his new zine, George Nebieridze captures moments of loud rage and quiet intimacy within the German capital’s female-only bands, while exploring the intersections between music, community and anti-establishment politics.

Written by: Miss Rosen

Group of people dancing at a live music performance, with a large "Spaces Beats" sign in the background.
Music

Amid tensions in Eastern Europe, young Latvians are reviving their country’s folk rhythms

Spaces Between the Beats — The Baltic nation’s ancient melodies have long been a symbol of resistance, but as Russia’s war with Ukraine rages on, new generations of singers and dancers are taking them to the mainstream.

Written by: Jack Styler

A person's face surrounded by colourful flowers. The flowers include orange, red, and yellow dahlias, as well as smaller yellow blooms. The person's expression is serious.
Music

Uwade: “I was determined to transcend popular opinion”

What Made Me — In this series, we ask artists and rebels about the about the forces and experiences that shaped who they are. Today, it’s Nigerian-born, South Carolina-raised indie-soul singer Uwade.

Written by: Uwade

Taxidermy alligator with a small monkey sitting on its head, displayed on a wooden shelf with other items.
Culture

Inside the obscured, closeted habitats of Britain’s exotic pets

“I have a few animals...” — For his new series, photographer Jonty Clark went behind closed doors to meet rare animal owners, finding ethical grey areas and close bonds.

Written by: Hannah Bentley

Muscular man with arms crossed in a dark setting, 'Hard Feelings' text overlay.
Sport

Frazer Clarke: “I had a hole in my leg, I’m very lucky to be alive”

Hard Feelings — For our interview column on masculinity and fatherhood, the Olympic boxing medallist speaks to Robert Kazandjian about hard graft, the fear and triumph of his first fight, and returning to the ring after being stabbed on a night out.

Written by: Robert Kazandjian

Close-up view of a woman in a vintage pose, with flowing hair and an outstretched hand, set against a hazy, scenic background.
© Peter Palladino, courtesy of the Peter Palladino Archive.
Culture

Remembering Holly Woodlawn, Andy Warhol muse and trans trailblazer

Love You Madly — A new book explores the actress’s rollercoaster life and story, who helped inspire Lou Reed’s ‘Walk on the Wild Side’.

Written by: Miss Rosen

Signup to our newsletter

Sign up to our newsletter to informed with the cutting edge of sport, music and counterculture, featuring personal takes on the state of media and pop culture from Emma Garland, former Digital Editor of Huck, exclusive interviews, recommendations and more.

Please wait...

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.