How surfers destroyed an idyllic Indonesian island

Premiering at London Surf Film Festival, Point of Change explores how the discovery of a ‘perfect wave’ wreaked havoc on the Indonesian island of Nias.

This is a tale of dis­ease, dis­ap­pear­ance and death – of black mag­ic, malar­ia, cul­ture clash­es and Coca Cola. It all began in the 1970s when two Aussie surfers stum­bled across the per­fect wave,’ a point on the remote Indone­sian island of Nias. Lit­tle did they know, their dis­cov­ery would set off a chain reac­tion that would have dev­as­tat­ing unin­tend­ed con­se­quences for this island community.

Point of Change is an award-win­ning doc­u­men­tary by Rebec­ca Coley that unearths a sto­ry that many surfers and islanders would pre­fer to for­get. Blend­ing pre­vi­ous­ly unseen Super 8 archive, con­tem­po­rary inter­views and ani­ma­tion, the film inves­ti­gates the dark forces that surfer colo­nial­ism’ can unleash. But by speak­ing to all par­ties, the film weaves a more nuanced nar­ra­tive, to reveal a sto­ry far more com­plex than mere­ly pos­i­tive or neg­a­tive effects. As always in life, real­i­ty is often a con­fus­ing shade of grey.

Ahead of the UK pre­mière of Point of Change at Lon­don Surf Film Fes­ti­val, Huck spoke to direc­tor Rebec­ca about surfing’s impact on tra­di­tion­al com­mu­ni­ties and telling this sen­si­tive tale from mul­ti­ple perspectives.

How did you learn about the sto­ry of the point on Nias? What made you feel there was a film there?

I first heard about Nias through friends when I was in Aus­tralia work­ing and stopped off on my way home. I loved the wave & there was some­thing about the place, I was intrigued by a feel­ing or vibe I couldn’t quite put my fin­ger on. It felt unlike any­where I’d ever been before in my life. I heard sto­ries about the first surfers and there were rumours of malar­ia and black mag­ic, so I was intrigued. Then as I began to dig deep­er, the more I found out, the more I knew this was an impor­tant sto­ry to tell.

On my jour­ney to mak­ing the film I vis­it­ed first as a tourist, then I vis­it­ed as part of an NGO aid trip after the tsuna­mi, then I stayed and lived for a cou­ple of years on and off. So, it was also through real­ly immers­ing in the cul­ture and hav­ing deep­er rela­tion­ships with peo­ple that the big­ger fea­ture film idea came to be.

Could you tell us a bit about the huge impact that surfers dis­cov­er­ing’ Nias had on the island and its people?

At first the locals didn’t know what to make of these white guys… They talked about the colo­nials return­ing. They didn’t know if they had guns or shields or what they were car­ry­ing. Then they saw them danc­ing on the water and they’re more curi­ous. Slow­ly trad­ing and com­mu­ni­ca­tion starts to hap­pen. Like any­thing, peo­ple try to keep a secret, but they also want to share an amaz­ing expe­ri­ence with friends. Slow­ly, word trick­les out and it wasn’t long before The Point was in surf mag­a­zines and films. The pin­na­cle was Coca Cola turn­ing up to make a com­mer­cial there. The unin­tend­ed con­se­quences were open­ing the flood­gates, I guess, but they nev­er could have known how crazy it would get. 

The film tries to walk the line in that big grey area in the mid­dle where there are pos­i­tives and neg­a­tives effects of all that hap­pens. Yes par­adise’ isn’t pris­tine any­more, and that is dev­as­tat­ing. But some­one like Bonne Gea who is a local mus­lim girl, becomes Indonesia’s first woman cham­pi­on surfer & Asian cham­pi­on surfer and escapes a life of arranged mar­riage she didn’t want, so she is hap­py about it. So it is com­pli­cat­ed and there are dif­fer­ent lay­ers to it.

How did you set­tle on this hybrid doc­u­men­tary style to tell this story?

Kevin and John went to Nias in 1975 with their Super 8 cam­era and tri­pod, so there’s this beau­ti­ful, mag­i­cal footage of Lagun­di Bay exact­ly as they found it. It took a while to track that down in someone’s attic and get it telecined. I don’t want to spoil the sto­ry but there’s also amaz­ing footage of 1976 and more of the char­ac­ters who turned up. That was an amaz­ing moment to realise we had some­thing to tell that part of the sto­ry. But it wasn’t enough. 

We also had the chal­lenge of bring­ing all these dif­fer­ent for­mats togeth­er. I’d shot with var­i­ous dig­i­tal cam­eras over the years and we had all these dif­fer­ent aspect ratios and for­mats for all the dif­fer­ent footage, so that was anoth­er part of why we land­ed on ani­ma­tion. We worked on the sto­ry as being a jour­ney through time that suit­ed the var­i­ous for­mats, but also worked for the over­all themes of the film. 

The ani­ma­tion is like the sub­con­scious of the film and adds lay­ers to the mean­ing. We only used ani­ma­tion in those impor­tant moments where we need­ed to tell a part of the sto­ry we had noth­ing else for, but was also an impor­tant beat in the film. I met Maxime, who did all the ani­ma­tion, in a pub in New Cross about ten years ear­li­er and we talked about it a lot before we were final­ly able to afford to do it. 

For the 80s sec­tion I met Dick Hoole at his house in Byron Bay and we went through his 16mm on a Steen­beck edit­ing machine, which was great as a cel­lu­loid lover. He let us use some unseen footage from his trips to make Storm Rid­ers and Asian Par­adise in the late 70s and 80s, but again it took a while. With the help of the Aus­tralian Surf Film Archive we got the footage digi­tised, telecined, grad­ed etc. 

I always felt the sto­ry deserved to be so much more than talk­ing heads and so there’s a cre­ative approach to retelling the his­to­ry. Includ­ing the locals’ per­spec­tive and mix­ing the archive and ani­ma­tion in an evoca­tive way, hope­ful­ly takes the audi­ence on this odyssey through time.

Does surf­ing have a colo­nial mind­set’ prob­lem? How did you broach this issue in the film?

That’s a big ques­tion and a short answer is yes, to an extent. Of course, every surfer is dif­fer­ent and every local is dif­fer­ent and every place is dif­fer­ent. But just by the nature of the fact that we as West­ern­ers’ are priv­i­leged to trav­el to these des­ti­na­tions and have an eco­nom­ic advan­tage, means that even with­out mean­ing to, we can have an impact we might not intend. So being aware of that is the first step to change. In the film, I give the con­text of the his­to­ry of colo­nial­ism in Nias to under­stand the locals’ per­spec­tive, give con­text to what hap­pens next and to let peo­ple make up their own minds. Nowa­days it might not be a con­scious type of colo­nial­ism, how­ev­er all that has gone before has led us to where we are today. So the prob­lem is that we are only there and able to inter­act in the way we do in the con­text of all that has gone before.

What are the lessons we can draw from the sto­ry of Nias? Do you think surf­ing is begin­ning to recog­nise the impact it can have on frag­ile com­mu­ni­ties – or is there still lots of work to be done?

I want the audi­ence to watch the film and make up their own mind. I like the fact that so far audi­ences have come out with lots of ques­tions. That’s inter­est­ing and is how we can get the con­ver­sa­tions going.

Yes, I think some surfers recog­nise that and there is change hap­pen­ing on some lev­el for sure and that is great. If we take surf­ing out of it — it’s an issue in lots of dif­fer­ent sports and activ­i­ties and places. So there’s hope, surf­ing can be a force for good, too. But there’s def­i­nite­ly still work to be done. 

Lon­don Surf Film Fes­ti­val presents the UK pre­mière of Point of Change, plus a spe­cial film­mak­er Q&A with direc­tor Rebec­ca Coley on Thurs­day Novem­ber 23 at River­side Stu­dios.

You might like

Smiling person in black wetsuit riding surfboard on calm ocean with rocky hills in background.
Sport

Maryam El Gardoum is breaking new shores for Morocco’s indigenous surfers

The Amazigh Atlantic — Through her groundbreaking career and popular surf school, the five-time Moroccan champion is helping women find their places in the waves.

Written by: Sam Haddad

Colourful embroidered jackets worn by two people, with skateboarder visible in background. Bright colours and graphic designs on the clothing.
Sport

Volcom teams up with Bob Mollema for the latest in its Featured Artist Series

True to This — The boardsports lifestyle brand will host an art show in Biarritz to celebrate the Dutch illustrators’ second capsule collection.

Written by: Huck

Three individuals in swimming attire holding surfboards, standing in a field with cacti in the background.
Sport

A new documentary spotlights Ecuador’s women surfers fighting climate change

Ceibo — Co-directed by Maddie Meddings and Lucy Small, the film focuses on the work and story of Pacha Light, a wave rider who lived off-grid before reconnecting with her country’s activist heritage.

Written by: Hannah Bentley

Surfers against sewage protest box floating in water with people swimming around it.
© Alex Brown / Surfers Against Sewage
Sport

The rebellious roots of Cornwall’s surfing scene

100 years of waveriding — Despite past attempts to ban the sport from beaches, surfers have remained as integral, conservationist presences in England’s southwestern tip. A new exhibition in Falmouth traces its long history in the area.

Written by: Ella Glossop

Two surfers riding waves in the ocean, with spray and ocean in the background.
© Maria Riley
Sport

In Queens, local surfers are moulding a neighbourhood in their own renegade images

Rockaway breaks — On a little-known stretch of beach in eastern New York City, an ecosystem of wave catchers, and the local bars and restaurants that fuel them, is seeing a boom. Paolo Bicchieri meets the residents and business owners behind the growing swell.

Written by: Paolo Bicchieri

Photography

The Chinese youth movement ditching big cities for the coast

In ’Fissure of a Sweetdream’ photographer Jialin Yan documents the growing number of Chinese young people turning their backs on careerist grind in favour of a slower pace of life on Hainan Island.

Written by: Isaac Muk

Huck is supported by our readers, subscribers and Club Huck members. It is also made possible by sponsorship from:

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.