US police chiefs look to UK for help tackling a culture of violence

US police chiefs look to UK for help tackling a culture of violence
Fixing a broken police culture — Trust in American police is at a 22-year low. Now Senior officers are exploring if unarmed officers could challenge a culture of institutional brutality.

America’s faith in its police force has dropped to a 22-year low. In an age of camera phones and high-profile protests, it has become harder for heavy-handed or violent cops to avoid scrutiny over their actions. Today just 52% of American’s express confidence in the police, a low not recorded since 1993: the year after officers who were filmed beating Rodney King were acquitted, sparking the 1992 LA riots.

Conscious of the suspicion many citizens now hold for the police, some officers themselves have begun to question the behaviours seemingly ingrained in cop culture. In early December, police officials from several American states descended on the small Scottish town of Tulliallan as part of a lecture series on the benefits of policing without the use of guns. There was a mixed response. According to the New York Times, several officials reacted with surprise and scepticism to claims that unarmed policing is at all possible without endangering police officers themselves.

For many international observers, the gun-toting aggression of American police can be baffling. Although the threat of terrorism has made some call for an increase in armed officers, UK police on patrol are routinely unarmed. They only call on armed squads in rare instances where back-up is needed. A spokesperson for the National Police Chiefs’ Council told Huck, “The British model of policing has always relied on close links between the public and the police, from neighbourhoods upwards. Minimum use of force is a vital part of that relationship.”

It’s a noteworthy distinction. Whether it’s always successful is up for debate, but British police forces were founded on the idea of policing by consent and at least aspire to work in partnership with the general public. Their American counterparts, by contrast appear to prefer an unflinchingly authoritative stance.

Photo: Thomas Hawk

Photo: Thomas Hawk

In Scotland — where 98 percent of police officers do not carry  guns — American officers asked how they could ever withdraw the use of guns, while tackling a populace armed to the teeth with them. A Catch-22 scenario it would seem. Speaking to the Guardian, Ohio State psychology professor Brad Bushman argued a culture of guns can’t help but create an echoing culture of violence. “Weapons increase all of those aggressive thoughts, feelings, hostile appraisals and the type of thinking that somebody’s out to get you, or wants to hurt you.” Statistics show states with the most guns subsequently have the most gun-related homicides.

One unexpected roadblocks to tackling institutional police brutality is machismo. Speaking at a 2015 policing conference, and reported by the New York Times, Dallas police chief David O. Brown claims young officers see any form of retreat as a sign of weakness. “Sometimes it seems like our young officers want to get into an athletic event with people they want to arrest,” he said. “They feel like they’re warriors and they can’t back down when someone is running from them, no matter how minor the underlying crime is.”

American police officers are trained overwhelmingly in technical aspects of the use of force, but very little when it comes to the psychological. Or how to use empathy and reason to subdue an individual as opposed to exploiting brute force. This attitude can lead to incidents like a homeless disabled man alleged to be creating a scene being pulled down and pinned to the ground by five armed men, as caught on video in August – rather than calmly spoken to.

David C. Couper is a police chief turned pastor based in Wisconsin, whose blog Improving Police regularly discusses ways to reform the force. He told Huck, writes on his site, “America is a violent society with too many guns and too much fear of terrorism since 9/11 and the invasions of Iraq and Afghanistan. It’s deeply affected our nation’s police.”

Couper believes the key to improving relations between police and citizens is by approaching situations with a softness as opposed to a confrontational, reactionary rage. He also suggests repairing the image of the force through a shake-up of its ethnic make-up. While the number of non-white police in the United States continues to rise, they still make up just 27 percent of local police officers when they account for 37% of the population. He says, “Demilitarising our police from that of a warrior mentality to being protective guardians committed to saving lives and unconditionally respecting all persons will go a long way toward solving the contagious disease of violence. Along with controlling the possession of firearms, and assuring the civil rights of everyone regardless of class, gender, race, or immigration status. Add to this educated, committed, and ethical police leaders and it may be solved in my lifetime.”

Couper writes on his site, “We unknowingly fell into a system of criminal justice in America that has become oriented more toward domination than problem-solving, more toward arrest and incarceration than prevention and treatment.”

The rise of camera phones and increased scrutiny of police behaviour means we’re bearing witness to more and more police brutality, which often seems devoid of rational sense. Think Eric Garner being choked to death or young black teens being violently manhandled in high school classrooms,

There is a problem at the heart of police ethics in the United States but police chiefs aren’t burying their heads in the sand. With trust in the police at a 22-year low, the question now being asked by many in charge is how to reform and move forward.

Increasing diversity, police chiefs continuing to look at progressive procedural forces for guidance and soul-searching on the part of officers themselves, is leading to gradual change. Many officers welcome the shift in culture towards focus on compassion and protecting citizens, away from implementing brutish, violent forms of justice.

Whatever bright ideas can play a part a part, figures indicate how urgently change is needed: in the UK, police have killed 55 people in the UK since 1980, while police in the United States have killed 1147 in 2015 alone.

Enjoyed this article? Like Huck on Facebook or follow us on Twitter.

Latest on Huck

Fragile, intimate portraits of California’s imprisoned youth
Photography

Fragile, intimate portraits of California’s imprisoned youth

New monograph ‘A Poor Imitation of Death’ documents and humanises the stories of seven young Californian inmates, aged between 16 and 20 years old, who were tried as adults despite being juveniles.

Written by: Isaac Muk

I was made homeless 11 days after the Asylum decision I waited 16 years for
Election 2024

I was made homeless 11 days after the Asylum decision I waited 16 years for

After spending years waiting for a decision on his refugee status torture survivor Gideon discovered his traumatic fight for security was far from over.

Written by: Gideon, a client at Freedom from Torture

Save the date for Rishi’s Leaving Drinks
Election 2024

Save the date for Rishi’s Leaving Drinks

Huck is teaming up with our friends at Dalston Superstore and Queer House Party to bring you an election night viewing party like no other.

Written by: Ben Smoke

Activists claim victory after major UK festivals drop Barclays as a sponsor
Activism

Activists claim victory after major UK festivals drop Barclays as a sponsor

Groups and artists have been campaigning for Live Nation to drop the bank as a sponsor for Download, Latitude and Isle of Wight over alleged ties to the arms trade.

Written by: Ben Smoke

Exploring the football fanatic culture of the Middle East
Outdoors

Exploring the football fanatic culture of the Middle East

New photo book ‘Football كرة القدم’ draws together pictures from over a dozen photographers to explore the region’s vibrant football culture.

Written by: Isaac Muk

Drag artists unite to get out the vote, babes
Election 2024

Drag artists unite to get out the vote, babes

East London legend Crystal talks to Huck about her new campaign, Vote, Babes! which brings together over 20 drag artists to encourage young people to use their vote.

Written by: Ben Smoke

Sign up to our newsletter

Issue 80: The Ziwe issue

Buy it now