Austerity is the real enemy of women – not trans people

The fight for funding — A dearth of compassion for trans people makes it easier to pit them against cis women and children. But the true evil is right under our noses, writes Nicola Dinan.

A few weeks ago, the Sunday Times reported that long-delayed reform of the Gender Recognition Act (GRA) would not go ahead, despite support by a large majority of respondents to the Government’s consultation. GRA-reform would have allowed trans people to change their birth certificates by self-declaration (self-ID) as opposed to a review by a Gender Recognition Panel. The report of the rollback was accompanied by suggestions of “new lavatory guidelines”, further safeguards to protect “safe-spaces” for (cis) women, and a crackdown on “quack doctors”, echoing proposals from April to restrict care for trans kids.

The debate around trans rights has become inseparable from its price, which, it’s claimed, comes at the cost of cis women and children. The conversation often focuses on how to “balance” the rights between these competing parties. But I don’t think our Government, which is led by the same party that oversaw austerity, minds too much. After all, a balancing of rights dissolves solidarity and distracts from the real issue: insufficient funding. 

Rising tensions over women-only domestic violence refuges embody this, particularly in the context of GRA-reform. Answers to the question of whether trans women belong in women-only refuges have grown into a blaring cacophony. This is despite research showing that refuges consider that their procedures would protect against men abusing GRA-reform to access vulnerable women. So loud is the noise that you may even forget that these services are in a funding crisis

According to Women’s Aid, 64 per cent of referrals are declined, the main reason being a lack of space or capacity. Trans women are not to blame for this. However, in a climate where women – cis and trans – are turned away, it is easier to scapegoat trans women than to ask the harder question: why does a refuge have to turn any woman away, cis or trans?

It is therefore no surprise that the Government will likely placate trans-exclusionary groups with bureaucratic solutions – “guidelines” and rolling back GRA-reform – rather than a commitment to funding. This should not satisfy anyone. It is a far less meaningful outcome than entrusting domestic violence refuges with more resources, which would allow them to enforce their own tested procedures safely, manage concerns around GRA reform, and continue to provide refuge to vulnerable trans people. More resources also mean more beds for people who aren’t trans, as well as more prevention and therapeutic services work – the alternative often being a pipeline to a prison cell.

This chronic underfunding has also spread to our NHS. Whilst NHS England has increased the budget assigned to children’s and adults’ gender identity services, this is nowhere near in line with the increase in demand for these services. This is reflected in waiting times. Currently, the Tavistock and Portman Trust are booking appointments for adults who have waited an average of 33-36 months, and children who have waited an average of 22-26 months for their first appointment. 

The Sunday Times report suggested that treatment for trans people would require “greater sign-off”.  If this meant more therapy and support and less waiting, then I am sure many would be in favour. However, there has been little mention of substantially increasing funding commitments. This means that adding further layers of approval will cause a static pool of resources to vest in fewer people. Enforcing “greater sign-off” will therefore harm adults and children who genuinely need to transition, as well as those for whom transition is not the right path.
Problems will also not go away in a three-year-long queue. Firstly, studies on desistance overestimate teens with gender dysphoria who “grow out of it”, and it is difficult to imagine that complex issues which make someone wrongly think they are trans will work themselves out on their own. It is also worth noting that fewer than half of the under-18s referred to the Gender Identity Development Service, a provider of trans healthcare, go on to have any physical treatments anyway.

A dearth of compassion for trans people makes it easier to pit them against cis women and children. It also trivialises their needs: when a section of the public assumes that all a trans person needs to thrive is new clothes and a deed poll, anything more becomes a trespass on public decency. Trans people need much more. Trans women, for example, do not want to enter domestic violence refuges for validation, but because they are often victims of domestic violence too (at twice the rate of cis women). 

In 2017, Angela Davis was interviewed at the Women of the World Festival in Southbank. She questioned, “who’s going to be in a position to penetrate the glass ceiling if not those who are already on top?” Quoting her friend Michael Bennett, she directed focus toward women “for whom the floor underneath them is constantly collapsing”. The metaphor has stuck with me. 

I question what it says about a Government’s policies, and a person’s politics, when “protecting” women and children takes the form of symbolic gestures which continue to leave the vulnerable on the floor. I also question the integrity of these gestures when they are the fruit of an increasingly hostile climate toward trans people. I question, finally: is this what dismantling the patriarchy is supposed to look like? 

Follow Nicola Dinan on Twitter.

Enjoyed this article? Like Huck on Facebook or follow us on Twitter.


You might like

Dimly lit underground carpark, long winding corridor with concrete walls, floor, and pipes above.
Activism

Youth violence’s rise is deeply concerning, but mass hysteria doesn’t help

Safe — On Knife Crime Awareness Week, writer, podcaster and youth worker Ciaran Thapar reflects on the presence of violent content online, growing awareness about the need for action, and the two decades since Saul Dibb’s Bullet Boy.

Written by: Ciaran Thapar

Surfers against sewage protest box floating in water with people swimming around it.
© Alex Brown / Surfers Against Sewage
Sport

The rebellious roots of Cornwall’s surfing scene

100 years of waveriding — Despite past attempts to ban the sport from beaches, surfers have remained as integral, conservationist presences in England’s southwestern tip. A new exhibition in Falmouth traces its long history in the area.

Written by: Ella Glossop

Indoor skate park with ramps, riders, and abstract architectural elements in blue, white, and black tones.
Sport

In England’s rural north, skateboarding is femme

Zine scene — A new project from visual artist Juliet Klottrup, ‘Skate Like a Lass’, spotlights the FLINTA+ collectives who are redefining what it means to be a skater.

Written by: Zahra Onsori

Couple sitting on ground in book-filled environment
Culture

The British intimacy of ‘the afters’

Not Going Home — In 1998, photographer Mischa Haller travelled to nightclubs just as their doors were shutting and dancers streamed out onto the streets, capturing the country’s partying youth in the early morning haze.

Written by: Ella Glossop

Activism

How trans rights activism and sex workers’ solidarity emerged in the ’70s and ’80s

Shoulder to Shoulder — In this extract from writer Jake Hall’s new book, which deep dives into the history of queer activism and coalition, they explore how anti-TERF and anti-SWERF campaigning developed from the same cloth.

Written by: Jake Hall

Opinion

Stand Up Paddle Boarding

Screw It! — Miles Masterson vents his frustration as the stand up paddle boarding apocalypse sweeps his homebreak.

Written by: Miles Masterson

Huck is supported by our readers, subscribers and Club Huck members. It is also made possible by sponsorship from:

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.