The British government thinks 10 year prison sentences are the answer to online piracy
- Text by Natasha Turner
- Photography by via Splitshare
Ever since those ’90s ‘you wouldn’t steal a car’ adverts in the cinema, the British public has been getting to grips with its piracy problem. Stealing art is often damaging, however much we love it, and something’s got to give.
But now the UK government has taken clampdown measures to the extreme. Under cover of the Queen’s birthday celebrations last Thursday, it decided to recommend tougher punishments for people caught illegally downloading online – to the tune of a maximum of ten years’ imprisonment.
This makes it the same or a higher sentence than those given for crimes such as child cruelty and some firearms offences. When the average length of a prison sentence for rape in the UK is just over eight years, ten years for piracy seems particularly draconian.
The government’s suggestion was published following a study and public consultation. The proposal for the sentence to be increased from two to ten years’ imprisonment (bringing it in line with the maximum sentence for offline copyright offences) will be put before parliament as soon as possible.
In March 2015, a study commissioned by the Intellectual Property Office concluded that two-year sentences for copyright infringement sent out the message that piracy was not a serious crime. The study suggested the eight-year increase be imposed. Then in July 2015, 1,032 people were consulted on the idea. 98 per cent of the respondents said that they opposed tougher sentencing. The few in support were largely businesses and organisations, which have the most to lose.
The majority of opposition came from the Open Rights Campaign group. They raised a numbers of concerns with the proposal, including the fact that there was no scope allowed for those unaware that they were committing a crime. In light of these concerns, Thursday’s report states that offenders will be notified of their wrongdoing by authorities before action is brought against them.
In a foreword to the report, parliamentary under-secretary of state and minister for intellectual property, Baroness Neville-Rolfe, said: “The provision of a maximum ten year sentence is designed to send a clear message to criminals that exploiting the intellectual property of others online without their permission is not acceptable.”
Copyright infringement is a problem but its scope is relatively unknown. In 2001, Adobe reported that $13 billion had been lost from the world economy in tax revenue and job losses due to piracy. But a study in 2013 by the European Commission Joint Research Centre found that an increase in illegal downloads actually led to a small increase in legal music sales.
Online copyright infringement needs to be recognised as a serious crime and independent artists need systems that will support their work. But whether harsh criminal measures will work as a deterrent remains to be seen.
Enjoyed this article? Like Huck on Facebook or follow us on Twitter.
You might like
“I didn’t care if I got sacked”: Sleazenation’s Scott King in conversation with Radge’s Meg McWilliams
Radgenation — For our 20th Anniversary Issue, Huck’s editor Josh Jones sits down with the legendary art director and the founder of a new magazine from England’s northeast to talk about taking risks, crafting singular covers and disrupting the middle class dominance of the creative industries.
Written by: Josh Jones
Free-spirited, otherworldly portraits of Mexico City’s queer youth
Birds — Pieter Henket’s new collaborative photobook creates a stage for CDMX’s LGBTQ+ community to express themselves without limitations, styling themselves with wild outfits that subvert gender and tradition.
Written by: Isaac Muk
The suave style and subtle codes of gay San Francisco in the ’70s
Seminal Works — Hal Fischer’s new photobook explores the photographer’s archive, in which he documented the street fashion and culture of the city post-Gay Liberation, and pre-AIDS pandemic.
Written by: Miss Rosen
The stripped, DIY experimentalism of SHOOT zine
Zine Scene — Conceived by photographer Paul Mpagi Sepuya in the ’00s, the publication’s photos injected vulnerability into gay portraiture, and provided a window into the characters of the Brooklyn arts scene. A new photobook collates work made across its seven issues.
Written by: Miss Rosen
The heady bliss of Glastonbury Festival after the music
Not Done Yet — While the weekend’s headliners and stacked line-ups usually draws the majority of the attention, much of its magic occurs after the music stops. Mischa Haller’s new photobook captures the euphoria and endless possibilities of Glasto’s “in between” moments.
Written by: Isaac Muk
Joe Bloom’s View From a Bridge
More stories, more human — The artist and creator of the vertical video generation’s most loved storytelling platform explains the process behind creating the show, and the importance of bucking trends.
Written by: Isaac Muk
