The photographer pushing beyond violent cliches in… | Huck
Huck
Photography

The photographer pushing beyond violent cliches in post-apartheid Cape Town

Life on The Flats — Photographer Charlie Shoemaker has found a second home in a suburb of Cape Town where highs and lows are seldom captured in a balanced way.

Facreton is a small suburb in the Cape Flats, an infertile area of land just outside of Cape Town. It’s an area plagued by a complex web of issues that trace back to segregationist Apartheid-era laws, but for the best part of this year, it’s also been my second home.

I’ve been based in Cape Town for nearly three years, having spent a year prior in Uganda after relocating from the States. Earlier this year, I found myself unwittingly documenting the killing of seventeen-year-old Mansoer Odendaal, who was stabbed to death during a carnival I was documenting.
Daily life at the Nicolas family home on July 16, 2012. Nazeera is 4 months pregnant.HUCK_edit_Charlie_Shoemaker005
Mansoer was killed at the back of a busy bus that I happened to be standing outside of. People started breaking windows and passing children out, as a crowd covered in blood ran to the front of the bus to escape the fighting. No one knew what was happening inside.

After witnessing the chaos that erupted around his death, I wanted to meet Mansoer’s community and explore the place he called home. Facreton is only a twenty-minute drive from Cape Town’s city centre, but it’s worlds apart from the wealthy suburbs at the foot of Table Mountain.

Gaining access to a community that has to deal with some of the highest rates of homicide in the country – not to mention gang problems, poor education, high unemployment and lack of proper housing – wasn’t a quick or easy thing to do. But I was fortunate to have met many local residents while documenting Kenfac (Kensington-Facreton), a dance and marching band troupe made up of Facreton residents. Mansoer was a member of Kenfac, and it was during my time with the troupe that he was killed.HUCK_edit_Charlie_Shoemaker003HUCK_edit_Charlie_Shoemaker006
Thanks to the people I’d met during that period, I began spending more and more time in Facreton, meeting with activists and groups who were trying to see an end to the gang violence and drug dealing. I attended community meetings where I could speak to people and explain why I was there, what I hoped to achieve, and seek permission to allow me to work within their community.

Over time I came to know the Nicolas’ – a family of nine who have welcomed me into their home. It’s a relationship developed over countless hours of talking and being a part of normal family life. We’ve developed a mutual trust, respect and caring. I think a big reason why they allowed me in is because I didn’t run away in the chaos of Mansoer’s stabbing. In a way, I’ve paid my dues.
HUCK_edit_Charlie_Shoemaker004
I never set out to tell a ‘gang’ or ‘drug’ story in the Flats. There are already too many of those in the media, and the negative picture they paint is often all we see. I feel a responsibility to show the highs and lows of my subjects’ lives. Life is a daily struggle in Facreton for many, but that doesn’t mean it’s terrible either. Some of the nicest and most welcoming South Africans I’ve met live in this community, offering me their only meal of the day or spending all the money they have to buy me a soda.HUCK_edit_Charlie_Shoemaker008HUCK_edit_Charlie_Shoemaker009
I’ve been amazed at how well people have responded to my role as a documentary photographer in their lives. I’ve never had to question the legitimacy of their actions because the camera was present. I’ve actually been in situations where I was convinced no one would want me to document what I was seeing, only to be questioned why I wasn’t picking up my camera to take photos. They want to show me the reality of their lives, the good and the bad, no matter the circumstances.

See more of Charlie’s work on his website.

This article originally appeared in Huck 41 – The Documentary Photography Special I. Order a copy in the Huck Shop  or subscribe today to make sure you don’t miss another issue.

Enjoyed this article? Like Huck on Facebook or follow us on Twitter.


You might like

Group of children on a city street, one wearing a werewolf mask, others pulling scary faces and raising hands toward camera. Black and white.

Halloween in Brooklyn, photographed over 50 years

Spirits and soul — Larry Racioppo’s new book documents half a century of the October festivities in New York, while tracing the city’s ever-changing character.

  • Culture
  • Anna Stafford
Black and white close-up of a shirtless man lying down, city skyline visible behind him, other figures partially visible nearby.

Cruising on the West Side Piers, New York’s wild side

West Side Highway — In the late 20th century, the area was an if-you-know-you-know hotspot for the city’s gay scene. William Howell’s new photobook immortalises it.

  • Culture
  • Miss Rosen
Members Only
Young woman on a city pavement holding a lamppost, wearing a black leather jacket, white top, and red-orange maxi skirt.

Ahilya Bamroo is Gen Z India’s authentic ambassador

Reel relatable — The influencer turned actor speaks about trolls, beauty standards and youth activism.

  • Huck 84: It Starts With Us
  • Radhika Iyengar
Two men talking indoors near large printed photos on a wall; one in a camo jacket, the other in a black hoodie and cap.

What went down at Huck’s 20th birthday party

84 issues and counting — We took over east London’s Jaguar Shoes with friends old and new to celebrate two decades and our new issue, with Tony Bontana taking the decks for a special set.

  • Huck 84: It Starts With Us
  • Ella Glossop

Photos of friends, lovers and afters in Berlin’s party scene

Dreams and How to Keep Them – Vincent Wechselberger’s new monograph documents a decade of hedonism in the German capital, and the people he met along the way.

  • Music
  • Hannah Mildner

Inside the Los Angeles scene kid revival

The Rawring ’20s — For the cover of Huck 84, photographer Alexis Gross and writer Anna Zanes meet the latest faces of scene, who are finding freedom to express themselves through its technicolour, unafraid aesthetic.

  • Huck 84: It Starts With Us
  • Anna Zanes
You've read articles this month Thanks for reading

Join Club Huck — it's free!

Valued Huck reader, thank you for engaging with our journalism and taking an interest in our dispatches from the sharp edge of culture, sport, music and rebellion.

We want to offer you the chance to join Club Huck [it's free!] where you will receive exclusive newsletters, including personal takes on the state of pop culture and media from columnist Emma Garland, culture recommendations, interviews and dispatches straight to your inbox.

You'll also get priority access to Huck events, merch discounts, and more fun surprises.

Already part of the club? Enter your email above and we'll get you logged in.