Minority students' futures are under threat in the United States
- Text by Adam White
- Photography by Pexels.com
A 25-year-old white woman could be the biggest legal threat to minority rights in United States higher education in over a decade. On December 9, Congress hears arguments in the case of Abigail Fisher v. University of Texas, a lengthy court battle inspired by the apparent racial discrimination Fisher experienced when she was not accepted into the university in 2008.
It’s a challenge to affirmative action in the USA, a concept introduced in the 1960’s to ensure the same opportunities are granted to everyone regardless of gender, race or socio-economic background. The definition of what constitutes ‘affirmative action’ has varied over time and in different settings, but is often used as an attempt to redress America’s longstanding bias against minorities. Enforced in laws at state and federal levels, it has always been a controversial concept, loathed by the right-wing.
Fisher argues that her race played a significant role in her rejection from the university, whose admission procedures determine that Texas high school graduates who fail to hit the top 10% of their class are judged on other personal achievements and characteristics. Among them extra-curricular activities, work experience and race, of which the university says makes up roughly 25% of the deciding factor. The university’s board of admissions has claimed that Fisher would not have been admitted into their college regardless of her race, but she isn’t convinced. Despite the demographics of the 2008 freshman class being just 6% black and 20% Hispanic, Fisher claims the ruling violated her constitutional rights, the fourth amendment declaring that all states should provide equality to its citizens.
Taking race into account in admissions procedures has long been controversial. It was last significantly discussed by government in 2003, but Congress has traditionally upheld affirmative action laws, which are designed to favour minority candidates and promote diverse educational spaces. This is Fisher’s second time appearing before Congress to argue her case. Judges favoured the University of Texas in 2013, but there are concerns about what a possible win for Fisher this time could mean for colleges across the country. “There is a lot at stake here,” NAACP attorney Rachel Kleinman told the San-Antonio Express. “Any ruling that technically applies to UT will certainly have other colleges and universities scrambling to make sure they’re in compliance.”
The racial make-up of American campuses has been making headline news for months. The #StudentBlackOut protests across the country, spearheaded by concerns about “everyday racism” at the University of Missouri, has led to a wider discussion about the lack of non-white faculty members and racial elitism in university culture. Statistics also show that the number of black students entering top-tier colleges in the United States shrunk significantly between 1994 and 2013, while the number of other minority undergraduates has gone up.
Educational inequalities in the university system are finally being given voice, but the Fisher case could deliver a significant blow to efforts to make university campuses greater resemble the world around us.
Enjoyed this article? Like Huck on Facebook or follow us on Twitter.
You might like
The last days of St Agnes Place, London’s longest ever running squat
Off the grid — Photographer Janine Wiedel spent four years documenting the people of the Kennington squat, who for decades made a forgotten row of terraced houses a home.
Written by: Isaac Muk
As salmon farming booms, Icelanders size up an existential threat
Seyðisfjörður — The industry has seen huge growth in recent years, with millions of fish being farmed in the Atlantic Ocean. But who benefits from its commercial success, and what does it mean for the ocean? Phil Young ventures to the remote country to find out.
Written by: Phil Young
Activists hack London billboards to call out big tech harm
Tax Big Tech: With UK youth mental health services under strain, guerrilla billboards across the capital accuse social media companies of profiting from a growing crisis.
Written by: Ella Glossop
In photos: The boys of the Bibby Stockholm
Bibby Boys — A new exhibition by Theo McInnes and Thomas Ralph documents the men who lived on the three-story barge in Dorset, giving them the chance to control their own narrative.
Written by: Thomas Ralph
‘We’re going to stop you’: House Against Hate tap Ben UFO, Greentea Peng and Shygirl for anti-far right protest
R3 Soundsystem — It takes place on March 28 in London’s Trafalgar Square, with a huge line-up of DJs, artists and crews named on the line-up.
Written by: Ella Glossop
In photos: Lebanon’s women against a backdrop of war
Where Do I Go? لوين روح — As war breaks out in the Middle East once again, we spotlight Rania Matar’s powerful new photobook, which empowers women of her home country through portraiture.
Written by: Miss Rosen
