How the British LGBT Awards became guilty of pinkwashing

Forgotten struggle — Activists are calling out the MI6's sponsorship of the awards ceremony by pointing out just how antithetical it is to the roots of queer resistance.

When the names MI5 and MI6 are mentioned, they likely bring to mind dramatisations of men in suits with Bond-style gadgets. That they are two of many corporate sponsors of this year’s British LGBT Awards may, then, come as a surprise. To Chardine Taylor Stone, a musician, writer and queer activist, it was enough reason to send back her award for “Oustanding Contribution to LGBT+ Life” from four years ago.

She was not the only one to take issue with organisers’ choices of sponsors this year. Actress and Youtuber, Abigail Thorn (better known as the founder of Philosophy Tube) was nominated for an award at this year’s ceremony. Yet she cited “moral and political disagreements” with this year’s sponsors as triggering her decision to withdraw from the running.

Chardine describes this year’s choice of sponsors as an example of pinkwashing, referring to companies and governments’ appropriation of LGBTQ+ issues to avoid criticism. “Particularly now, we are seeing a veneer [created by] corporate social responsibility departments. In a nutshell, they exist to find ways to cover their exploitative practices, as a kind of avoidance of accountability,” she says.

Yet her horror at the British LGBT Awards’ choice of sponsors seems not to be merely at the inclusion of corporate interests. “Corporations are going to do what corporations do,” she says. “But I think a line needs to be drawn when it’s a government department that has done simply evil things, to be frank, and continues to do so.”

“They often say ‘well, we’re a small organisation so we need the money’,” she notes. “But I was playing Green Man Festival, and there’s no corporations there. At all.” Instead, Chardine points out that there are other routes for funding, such as maintaining good relationships with wealthy LGBTQ+ figures who might consider becoming donors.

In her public statement withdrawing from the running, Abigail Thorn elected not to explicitly name the sponsors which instigated her decision. In contrast, Chardine’s statement pointed fingers at MI5 and MI6, even going so far as to specify actions which trigger her deeply visceral response to the two institutions.

“We need to reconsider what our power is as a community,” she says. “People separate these issues out so they only engage with LGBTQ rights, but there are climate change activists who are LGBTQ and have been spied on by MI5. Are you then meant to choose between your two identities and your work?”

Curator, art historian and queer activist, Claire Mead, points out that LGBTQ+ activism has, historically, been rooted in anti-governmental resistance. “The problem when these organisations get involved and try to spin a narrative of championing LGBTQ+ representation within the sector is that we lose any kind of historical objectivity,” she says. “If [an organisation] is sponsoring an event, it’s more than likely that whatever is said may veer away from the critical, in terms of how these people were brutally erased and persecuted, going towards a much more sugar-coated, celebratory aspect.”

In her statement returning her award, Chardine mentions her identity as a Black, queer woman influencing her position. The statement describes her principles as being rooted in “international solidarity, anti-colonialism and anti-imperialism”. Indeed, particularly with regards to MI5 and MI6, the historical impact of such organisations has particularly been felt by communities of colour. 

Just ten years ago, for example, MI6 officers were encouraging British mercenaries to break a United Nations arms embargo on Sierra Leone. Private military company, Sandline International, was headed up by former staff office director of Special Forces, Tim Spicer, when it reinstated the country’s president, and shipped 30 tonnes of arms to the country in breach of the ban, purportedly with the Foreign Office’s approval.

Today, Pride and queer events, including the British LGBT awards, are home to a whole host of corporate interests. At popular marches and parades, companies hand out merchandise emblazoned with rainbow flags, their logos superimposed onto the bright, cheap plastic. Despite their historical position in raids and brutality against queer activists, the police have been seemingly rehabilitated, and can now often be found in vibrantly striped cars during Pride Month. 

Claire argues that the movement towards the corporate and the incorporation of government departments are “antithetical” to the roots of queer resistance. “[It’s important to] look at that moment at which pride shifted from being a political protest to being this overtly corporate exercise,” she says. 

“It goes back to whether or not we are really trying to have an intersectional movement… [as well as] who is in control of having these presences at Pride and other LGBTQI events, and how they completely disregard the safety of people who are attending: not just Black people and people of colour but also trans people, and disabled people.”

As mainstream queer events become more and more enmeshed with the corporate world, the question remains as to whom they stand for, and who will be left behind. For now, the rift between activists and the organisers of such events seems to be growing. This year has also seen other organisers coming under fire, including those of Manchester Pride, following the announcement that they would be cutting funding to charities. Chardine mentions that, at the time of interview, she has yet to hear from the organisers of the British LGBT Awards, despite having sent them her statement the night before it going public. 

The non-responsiveness seems to be a key trend: following widespread backlash to a tweet announcing their sponsors, the organisation deleted the post, but failed to address the community’s concerns. At the time of writing, they did not respond to a request for comment, either.

The future may seem unclear, but Chardine is looking to the past for inspiration. She hopes that the community can return to its “radical heart”. “What we are supposed to be working for and fighting for is not to make these corporations look good, but to support people in our community against things like homelessness and exploitation”, she says.

“I think people’s viewpoints are very self-centred, on their own success as an individual, or even just as a predominantly white community in the UK.” Until such a time in the movement comes, she remains defiant, calling on white queer counterparts to reconsider how they approach LGBTQ+ rights. 

To the board and others like it, she has a simple message. “It makes no sense to have an ethically dubious sponsor for what is, essentially, a human rights award. There’s a complete contradiction there,” she says. “We have a history – and a future – that we need to protect from being pilfered in this way.”

Follow Mishti Ali on Twitter

Enjoyed this article? Like Huck on Facebook or follow us on Twitter

 


You might like

A crowd of protesters holding placards and banners, including flags of Ireland, with "Defend the right to protest" and "Defend knee" written on them.
Activism

In photos: Hundreds gather outside court to protest Kneecap terror charge

‘Free Mo Charah’ — With drums, smoke and applause, protesters greeted the rapper outside court as he was released on unconditional bail.

Written by: Ella Glossop

Portrait of a bald man with glasses and a beard, set against a blurred background.
Activism

Misan Harriman: “The humanity I bear witness to is extraordinary”

Shoot the People — Following the premiere of a new film exploring the photographer’s work and driving forces, we caught up with him to chat about his rapid rise, shooting protests and the need for powerful documentarians in times of struggle.

Written by: Isaac Muk

Bus shelter display advertising Father's Day with orange and black text against an image of a man's face.
Activism

Campaigners hack UK bus ads on Father’s Day to demand Alaa Abd El-Fattah’s release

A father behind bars — Placing posters at bus stops around London, Leeds and Manchester, they called for greater action from foreign secretary David Lammy to reunite the British-Egyptian activist with his son and family.

Written by: Isaac Muk

Three smiling women wearing glamorous dresses and fur coats posing together.
Culture

The Getty Center’s first exclusively queer exhibition opens today

$3 Bill: Evidence of Queer Lives — Running until September, it features paintings, ephemera, video and photography to highlight LGBTQ+ histories, culture and people from 1900 to the present day.

Written by: Isaac Muk

Man singing at microphone on stage, wearing red shirt and tattoo on arm, playing electric guitar.
Activism

Green Day’s Billie Joe Armstrong tells ICE to “fuck off” in LA protest video

Saviors — The singer shared the post on Sunday, featuring the band’s recently released song ‘Fuck Off’ as its soundtrack.

Written by: Isaac Muk

Reportage

Boboshanti

21st Century Rasta — The commercial ubiquity of Rasta has led many followers to seek refuge in Boboshanti, a more orthodox interpretation of the creed. HUCK travelled to Jamaica to find out more.

Written by: Sarah Bentley

Huck is supported by our readers, subscribers and Club Huck members. It is also made possible by sponsorship from:

Signup to our newsletter

Sign up to our newsletter to informed with the cutting edge of sport, music and counterculture, featuring personal takes on the state of media and pop culture from Emma Garland, former Digital Editor of Huck, exclusive interviews, recommendations and more.

Please wait...