Malcolm X, O.J. Simpson, and now Marine Le Pen; a history of controversy at Oxford Union
- Text by Megan White
Hundreds of protesters have surrounded the Oxford Union ahead of French National Front leader Marine Le Pen’s scheduled appearance tonight, February 5.
By giving the far-right political party leader, a major force of French nationalism known for her fascist views, a platform on which to speak, the Union continues its tradition of being “the last bastion of free speech in the Western world”, as labelled by former Prime Minister Harold Macmillan.
The protest raises an important question around the topic of free speech – particularly pertinent following the recent Charlie Hebdo shootings. The success of the French National Front in last year’s European Elections, along with UKIP, comes as part of an increasing European shift to the right.
Lisa Wehden, President of the Oxford Union, defends the right of Le Pen to speak, telling The Oxford Student: “This continues the Oxford Union’s tradition of balancing information, education and entertainment. The Oxford Union is a politically-neutral institution. Our members have a variety of views as do our views as do our speakers, officers and staff. An invitation from the Union is not an endorsement of any particular agenda.
“The Union believes in the principle of freedom of speech and we would encourage all members who disagree with an invited speakers view to attend the event and question the speaker. We allow our members to meet people face to face and make their own minds up. We invite no speakers who do not accept the right of our members to question them. Marine Le Pen will be answering questions from the audience after her address.”
Ahead of le Pen’s appearance, Huck takes a look at the five most controversial people to speak at the Oxford Union.
Malcolm X
Human rights activist Malcolm X was an advocate for the rights of black people in the 1950s and 60s. He was, for a time, one of the most influential leaders of the Nation of Islam, a controversial Muslim group that was said to promote black supremacy.
In 1964 Malcolm X spoke at the union with the motion, “Extremism in the defence of liberty is no vice; moderation in the pursuit of justice is no virtue.” He addressed black exploitation at the hands of America, colonisation and imperialism.
Gerry Adams
Sinn Féin leader Gerry Adams has been one of the most important figures in the Northern Ireland peace process. He has consistently denied being a member of the Provisional IRA, however many have suggested that he was a key member of the terrorist group in the 1980s.
In 1983, he was elected president of Sinn Féin and became the first MP elected to the House of Commons for the party since the 1950s, although the party maintains its policy of absention from Westminster politics.
His voice was banned from being broadcast on television or radio by Margaret Thatcher in 1988, in order to prevent giving the IRA further coverage, however he appeared at the Union while still under this ban.
O.J. Simpson
O.J. Simpson is a retired American football player, who was accused of the murder of his ex-wife and one of her friends in 1994. The case became one of the most highly-publicised in American history, with television news coverage of Simpson driving to the police station to turn himself in receiving 95 million viewers worldwide. The trial was televised in its entirety.
Simpson gave his only UK appearance in 1996 following the end of his trial, speaking of police racism, apologising for hitting his ex-wife, whose murder he was acquitted of, and attacking the American news media. He is now in prison for numerous felonies, including armed robbery and kidnapping.
Nick Griffin
Having joined the British National Party in 1995, Griffin soon became notorious for his extreme far-right views including the removal of multiculturalism, re-introducing capital punishment and the repatriation of ethnic minorities. He was leader of the party from 1999 to 2014.
Griffin spoke at the Oxford Union in November 2007 as part of a free-speech forum alongside Holocaust denier David Irving. His invitation to speak was hugely criticised, with many believing the Union should refuse to give fascism a platform – the same debate people are having today surrounding Marine le Pen’s appearance.
Ian Paisley
Outspoken Northern Irish Unionist politician and Protestant leader Ian Paisley has always been a figurehead of controversy. Over the 65 years he was active as a minister, Paisley regularly preached against Catholicism, ecumenism and homosexualilty. He was, like Adams, involved in the Northern Irish Troubles, leading the Democratic Unionist Party for almost forty years.
Paisley used his appearance on an Irish peace process panel at the Oxford Union in 1962 to attack Catholicism, sparking further protests from many. When he appeared at the Union again in 1967, he openly mocked the Roman Catholic belief that the wafer was actually the flesh and blood of Christ.
You might like
A stark, confronting window into the global cocaine trade
Sangre Blanca — Mads Nissen’s new book is a close-up look at various stages of the drug’s journey, from production to consumption, and the violence that follows wherever it goes.
Written by: Isaac Muk
Venice Biennale will not award artists from Israel & Russia due to war crime accusations
Art Not Genocide — Both countries will still be allowed to exhibit work at their respective pavilions, but be excluded from judging considerations, as they have leaders facing arrest warrants issued by the International Criminal Court.
Written by: Noah Petersons
Confronting America’s history of violence against student protest
Through A Mirror, Darkly — In May 1970, two separate massacres at American college campuses saw deaths at the hands of the state. Naeem Mohaiemen’s new three-channel film memorialises the brutality.
Written by: Miss Rosen
Kneecap, Brian Eno, Erika de Casier sign Eurovision boycott letter protesting Israel’s involvement
No Music For Genocide — It calls upon the European Broadcasting Union to ban Israel from the upcoming competition, which is set to take place in Vienna between May 12 and May 14. Other signatories include Massive Attack, Hot Chip and Nadine Shah.
Written by: Sydney Lobe
“Madness can be overcome”: Robert Del Naja releases statement after Palestine Action arrest
“Small price to pay” — The Massive Attack frontman was one of more than 500 people detained on Saturday on suspicion of supporting Palestine Action, a group that has been banned under the Terrorism Act 2000 by the UK government.
Written by: Ella Glossop
Defiant photos of New York’s ’80s & ’90s queer activists
Arresting Images — Dona Ann McAdams’ photographs document the AIDS crisis, lesbian organising and civil disobedience from one of the most fraught eras in American LGBTQ+ history. A sale of her archive takes place later this month.
Written by: Sydney Lobe