Is political blackness past its sell by date?
- Text by Halimo Hussain
- Illustrations by Timba Smits
Identity is a complex notion, one that’s hard to define in a short sentence, or to boil down to single point. It figures, really, given how we each define and see ourselves can never truly be the same.
Sure, there are some characteristics that can pull us together: gender, sexuality, race and religion might break down into broad brush categories, but still there are sticking points, exceptions, moments where intersections and divergences need to be considered, celebrated and discussed.
Right now a question facing my own community is that of blackness, in particular what it means to be ‘politically black’. A term that’s rooted in the rich anti-racist organising of the 1970s and ‘80’s against far-right groups such as the National Front, political blackness is the idea that all non-white people can define themselves under one umbrella term: black.
Although once relevant, it’s now a deeply contested concept.
As a black woman of East African descent, a political affiliation to blackness wasn’t what drove my activism, instead it was a lived experience that affected the way I navigated through society. The first time I heard of political blackness was at university, and at first I found it difficult to grasp. This notion that someone could choose to identify as black, something that I didn’t consider a luxury to be opted into, felt somewhat alien to me.
This week I headed down to a panel discussion held as SOAS, a university in London, that was set to consider political blackness and its relevance today. The main question on everyone’s mind was whether it’s past its sell by date.
There was consensus amongst the mixture of students, academics, activists and beyond that it was vital to consider the issue right now. Police brutality and institutional racism seems to still specifically target African and Caribbean communities, but a rise in xenophobia, hate crime and racism across the country is hitting all of our communities hard.
Looking around during the opening remarks there was certainly a sense that people were present to express their dissatisfaction with the term.
Priscilla Mensah, the first black female president of Cambridge University Students’ Union was a member of the panel, and made it clear she couldn’t help but be “territorial about blackness”. While many organisations such as the Equality and Diversity Commission have moved away from the use of politically black, opting instead for terms like POC (people of colour) and BME (black minority ethnic), the National Union of Students in the UK continues to use it. Critical of political blackness, Mensah had herself proposed a motion to the NUS’ Black Students Campaign earlier this year, asking the organisation to make moves to renaming this strand of work. The motion wasn’t carried, but conversations are continuing.
Adam Muuse however, the current NUS Black Students Officer, emphasised the importance of Political blackness in uniting black and brown people both within the context of education and beyond. His argument would suggest there’s a unifying trait that non-white people in the UK share: that while the racism we each confront may differ, we are treated as the other, structures see us all that way
The people desperately waiting in the Calais jungle for refuge? Not white. Those targeted by the Government’s Prevent strategy? Not white. Those stopped and searched disproportionately by the police? Not white. “No one term is perfect”, suggested Muuse, “but we can only strive to make it meaningful by rooting in struggle”.
It became apparent that the tension in the debate lay in the conflation of a black ethnic identity and blackness in the political sense. Terminology it soon transpired was the main issue, not about splintering off our activism into factions. One audience member asked why we couldn’t just create a new term, one that allows us to maintain and build solidarity without using the term black. Murmurs around the room were in agreement.
Those upset about the term politically black suggested that ethnic language shouldn’t be the point of articulating shared political struggles, it’s a position that I would have to agree with. We need to find language that articulates what unifies us.
I can’t help but feel it’s worth examining why the term black is used in this context in the first place. Critics would argue that this only homogenises our experiences. We need a space to address particular experiences of anti-blackness: painful as it might be to accept, it’s not just white people who are responsible.
Listening to the discussion, there was mutual agreement that we need to provide space for nuance in discussions surrounding varying experiences amongst and within black and brown communities.
While I respect the anti-racist and anti-fascist history that political blackness was was born out of, a shift away from the term can’t just be rooted in criticism. We must recognise that it’s a call for self-reflection and evolution when politically organising against racist structures. Times change, and language must move with it. After listening closely I, like many others, can’t help but acknowledge that political blackness is probably now past its sell by date.
I suppose one sentence I heard that sums up where I find myself now came from Mensah: “Racial identity in the past is not how we should shape racial identity in the future.”
Enjoyed this article? Like Huck on Facebook or follow us on Twitter.
Latest on Huck
Have capitalists killed the internet?
At the start of the century, the internet was an escape from reality. Now, reality is an escape from the internet writes Huck Newsletter columnist Emma Garland.
Written by: Emma Garland
Why I’m taking action for rent control
On Saturday 14th December, people from across London will march to demand action on skyrocketing rents explains London Renters Union member Elyem Chej.
Written by: Elyem Chej
A portrait of love and loss in America today
‘Still Life: Photographs & Love Stories’ (Anthology Editions) is an intimate visual memoir of family, kinship, and community.
Written by: Miss Rosen
First acts for Boomtown 2025 revealed
Sex Pistols ft. Frank Carter, Azealia Banks and Nia Archives join Sean Paul, The Wurzels and Boney M at the award winning festival.
Written by: Ben Smoke
Sarah Jaffe: “The sense of anger amongst some men is masking a form of grief”
Our latest ‘Daddy Issues’ column features a raw and powerful interview with the American author exploring grief as a prism through which to understand the world and the people, systems, relationships and communities within it in.
Written by: Robert Kazandjian
Fontaines D.C. sponsor Ireland’s Bohemian FC’s new kit to raise money for Palestine
Made in partnership with the designers at the country’s oldest, 100 per cent fan owned football club, profits will go to Medical Aid for Palestinians.
Written by: Isaac Muk