Brazilian LGBTQ art show shut down by far-right protesters
- Text by Biju Belinky
This Sunday, Brazilian art exhibition Queermuseu – a show exploring the subjects of non-heteronormative gender expression and sexuality – was shut down after being targeted by far-right and evangelical groups.
The exhibition, hosted at the Santander Cultural Centre in Porto Alegre, featured over 260 works of art from 85 Brazilian artists, including Volpi, Lygia Clark and Portinari. It was curated by Gaudêncio Fidelis, and put together over the span of seven years. Having opened in early August, it was meant to be on display until October 8th.
The furore started after a video was shared on Facebook showing two male bloggers insulting the “pornographic” exhibition. Much of their outrage was directed at the art which referenced Catholic imagery – something to be expected in a show on LGBTQ art in a country where religion still dictates many aspects of everyday life and, in many cases, perpetuates prejudice and intolerance towards queer people.
In the video, the narrator addresses “fellow Christians” and laughs in a self-satisfied way when he is removed from the exhibit for filming without permission. “[Queer people] are already perverting the idea of family, of respect,” the man claims. “Now they’re making exhibitions promoting paedophilia, promoting promiscuity, even bestiality.”
F. Zago/Studio Z. Courtesy the artist
One of the artworks accused of “promoting pedophilia” was a set of paintings of LGBTQ children by artist Bia Leite, which were inspired by Criança Viada (or, in a rough translation “Queer Child”), a tumblr that collated photographs of children, who, from an early age, were not performing their gender “appropriately” – with non-heteronormative mannerisms, for example. The artwork, well-known within the community, sought to address the bullying suffered by LGBTQ children.
The outrage sparked by the Facebook video was largely backed and pushed forward by Movimento Brasil Livre – a hyper-nationalist right-wing movement with over 2.3 million likes on Facebook. They were also supported by various conservative evangelical and Catholic groups.
Within 72 hours, those opposed to the exhibition sent vitriol to Santander’s Facebook page, and began cancelling their accounts en masse. The bank, who hosted the show, eventually bowed to this pressure and decided to pull the exhibition.
In a statement released after the artworks’ removal, the bank acknowledged the protests and profusely apologised to anyone that might have been offended by the exhibit. “When art does not generate inclusion and positive reflection, it loses its greater purpose, which is to elevate the human condition,” the bank said in a statement.
Jaime Acioli / Courtesy Pinakotheke
The comments from the far right religious brigade, however, didn’t stop. “If you are a mother or father in the name of Jesus, cancel your account in this nefarious bank, that allows and defends religious intolerance, paedophilia and bestiality,” said one user. “Do not believe their apologies, do your bit, for a better country – a country with values, and especially for the protection of your family!!”
Many cried out for a new military intervention to put an end to all this “leftie nonsense,” with others claiming that the “Satanic” multimillion-dollar bank was run by “communists.”
After looking at over 200 pieces from the show, two district attorneys who specialise in the rights of children and adolescents attested there was absolutely no sign of paedophilia in any of the work.
Speaking to O Globo, curator Gaudêncio Fidelis, who was not notified before the exhibition was cancelled by Santander, stated: “I believe we have never had a case like this during the democratic period, where an exhibition is cancelled due to moral concerns about its content. In two, three days, groups organised to depreciate the show, connected to MBL (Movement Free Brazil) managed to create a completely skewed narrative of the artworks shown, which quickly went viral.”
“The fact that the institution gave in to these groups instead of positioning itself on the side of artists increases the severity of this episode. From now on, any group will feel that it’s within their rights to say what art should and shouldn’t be, and what people should see, hear.”
NINO CAIS. Courtesy the artist and Galeria Casa Triângulo
As much as the cowardice of the institution and the cancellation of the exhibit is infuriating and disheartening, it is unfortunately not surprising considering the current political climate in the country.
President Michel Temer leans heavily towards right-wing policies and has been repeatedly supported by evangelical leaders, who also control a great deal of the Brazilian government. As well as that, ever since the impeachment of president Dilma Roussef, many people have been leaning towards authoritarianism – something particularly dangerous considering Brazil’s violent dictatorial past.
On top of all that, the Brazilian trans community is constantly under attack, with the country having the highest murder rate of LGBTQ people in the world (144 murders of trans people were registered in 2016). The life expectancy of people within the trans community is little above 35 years. With the new wave of conservatism, things are only set to get harder.
Currently, people who are against the censorship of artworks have a petition going to re-open the exhibition. They also demonstrated in front of the Cultural Centre this Tuesday, holding signs against queer erasure. The protest ended with military police meeting protestors with stench bombs after they resisted.
Biju Belinky is Huck’s staff writer. Follow her on Twitter.
Enjoyed this article? Like Huck on Facebook or follow us on Twitter.
You might like
How Japan revolutionised art & photography in the ’60s and ’70s
From Angura to Provoke — A new photobook chronicles the radical avant-garde scene of the postwar period, whose subversion of the medium of image making remains shocking and groundbreaking to this day.
Written by: Miss Rosen
Leticia Bufoni is one of the greatest skaters ever. Now she’s tearing up asphalt.
Vamos, Leticia! — The Brazilian trailblazer helped rewrite the rulebook for women in skateboarding – and now she’s setting the pace behind the wheel for Porsche. For Huck’s 20th Anniversary Issue, she reflects on shredding stereotypes, building a career in male-dominated spaces, empowering the next generation, and the lessons that defined her journey.
Written by: Tracy Kawalik
The lacerating catharsis of body suspension in Hong Kong
Self-Ferrying — In one of the world’s most densely packed cities, an underground group of young people are piercing their skin and hanging their bodies with hooks in a shocking exploration of pain and pleasure. Sophie Liu goes to a session to understand why they partake in the extreme underground practice.
Written by: Sophie Liu
On The Mountain, Jamie Hewlett’s Gorillaz explore life after death
Going East — As everyone’s favourite animated band release their latest album, the visual artist behind it all catches up with Josh Jones to chat about the grief and spirituality underlining the record, as well as his learnings from how other cultures approach death and the afterlife.
Written by: Josh Jones
Why is the Amazon’s ‘great roar’ river wave shrinking?
Pororoca — Set in northern Brazil’s edge, a miles long tidal bore has become a destination for waveriders attempting its endless surf. But its future is uncertain, as landscape and weather changes have seen its power mellow in recent years.
Written by: Gaia Neiman
Clavicular isn’t interesting, really
Dreaming Small — The ‘looksmaxxer’ of the moment has garnered widespread furore over recent controversies. But newsletter columnist Emma Garland asks whether the 20-year-old influencer is actually doing anything that new, and what his rise says about modern turbo-nostalgia’s internet dominance.
Written by: Emma Garland
