Street artists bomb primetime with 'Homeland is racist’ graffiti
- Text by Alex King
As former CIA Agent Carrie Mathison leads German oligarch Otto Düring down an alley in a Syrian refugee camp, they pass an unassuming piece of graffiti in Arabic. Like most viewers, the network which aired this episode of the popular series Homeland on primetime TV, missed its significance. But for anyone with a good grasp of Arabic, they could read ‘Homeland is racist’ and see slogans mocking the show’s comically inaccurate portrayal of the Middle East peppered across the show’s set.
Street artists Heba Amin, Caram Kapp and Stone answered a call for “Arabian street artists” to help the show’s producers make their Syrian refugee camp set in Berlin look more authentic. Aware of the show’s reputation for its damaging portrayal of Muslims, initially they were skeptical, “until we considered what a moment of intervention could relay about our own and many others’ political discontent with the series,” they write in a statement on Heba Amin’s website. “It was our moment to make our point by subverting the message using the show itself.”
Top: we didn’t resist, so he conquered us riding on a donkey. Bottom: The situation is not to be trusted. Left: This show does not represent the views of the artists (photos courtesy of the artists)
If you haven’t watched the show, its grasp of the War on Terror and representation of Muslims and the Middle East is just a tiny degree less ridiculous than Team America. The plot is fictional, but misrepresentations such as Iran’s support for Al Qaeda in the show have been lapped up by the American public and even repeated on mainstream media. After five seasons, the artists argue, “the plot has come a long way, but the thinly veiled propaganda is no less blatant.”
In an age where so much mainstream entertainment glamourises conflict, sensationalises supposed threats and further embeds negative stereotypes, Huck asked Caram how we can we increase understanding of the Middle East, Arab culture and detoxify the narrative around the War on Terror. “We could question the image of an enemy ‘other’, created by a constant narrative of terror, war, images of extremists and burned flags in mainstream entertainment and news media,” he explains. “Rather than accept these as a fact of life, personal research and interactions can much influence perspectives and help develop a frame of mind in which a global society – which is so frequently proclaimed – is not an imaginary construct, but a way of life and understanding.”
Right: against the red, blue and purple devil (A Muslim Brotherhood reference made by an Egyptian general on Television in 2013)
Left: Homeland is a joke, and it didn’t make us laugh (photos courtesy of the artists)
The street art trio condemn the show for “maintain[ing] the dichotomy of the photogenic, mainly white, mostly American protector versus the evil and backwards Muslim threat.” In standard Hollywood style, when white characters such as Carrie Mathison shoot to kill, they’re ‘kickin’ ass’ and helping to keep America safe, but when their Arab foes use the same techniques they’re presented as an evil scourge.
They call Homeland out for, “Garner[ing] the reputation of being the most bigoted show on television for its inaccurate, undifferentiated and highly biased depiction of Arabs, Pakistanis, and Afghans, as well as its gross misrepresentations of the cities of Beirut, Islamabad – and the so-called Muslim world in general.”
Huck asked Caram what effect he hoped their intervention would have on Homeland viewers and the team that makes the show. “We hope that Homeland’s viewership will learn that the entertainment they are taking in is just that – entertainment,” he explains. “[That it’s] not a representation of the actual world, in which both the actions of the extremists the show so frequently depicts and their counterparts in the CIA, endanger and devalue the ways of life of a much larger population, both in the US and in the Middle East and SEA region. The crew will probably feature a couple of evil graffiti artists in an episode sometime next season, but we do hope they will interact a bit more with the subject matter they are dealing with and learn from it.”
Time will tell how much impact this artistic intervention has on Homeland, but being embarrassed so publicly on primetime TV might just prompt the show’s producers to do their homework in future.
Enjoyed this article? Like Huck on Facebook or follow us on Twitter.
Note: This article was amended on October 15, 2015 to include quotes from Huck’s interview with Caram Kapp.
You might like
The last days of St Agnes Place, London’s longest ever running squat
Off the grid — Photographer Janine Wiedel spent four years documenting the people of the Kennington squat, who for decades made a forgotten row of terraced houses a home.
Written by: Isaac Muk
As salmon farming booms, Icelanders size up an existential threat
Seyðisfjörður — The industry has seen huge growth in recent years, with millions of fish being farmed in the Atlantic Ocean. But who benefits from its commercial success, and what does it mean for the ocean? Phil Young ventures to the remote country to find out.
Written by: Phil Young
Activists hack London billboards to call out big tech harm
Tax Big Tech: With UK youth mental health services under strain, guerrilla billboards across the capital accuse social media companies of profiting from a growing crisis.
Written by: Ella Glossop
In photos: The boys of the Bibby Stockholm
Bibby Boys — A new exhibition by Theo McInnes and Thomas Ralph documents the men who lived on the three-story barge in Dorset, giving them the chance to control their own narrative.
Written by: Thomas Ralph
‘We’re going to stop you’: House Against Hate tap Ben UFO, Greentea Peng and Shygirl for anti-far right protest
R3 Soundsystem — It takes place on March 28 in London’s Trafalgar Square, with a huge line-up of DJs, artists and crews named on the line-up.
Written by: Ella Glossop
In photos: Lebanon’s women against a backdrop of war
Where Do I Go? لوين روح — As war breaks out in the Middle East once again, we spotlight Rania Matar’s powerful new photobook, which empowers women of her home country through portraiture.
Written by: Miss Rosen
