The everyday voices silenced in our coverage of the Middle East
- Text by Maysoon Pachachi
- Photography by Our River… Our Sky
![The everyday voices silenced in our coverage of the Middle East](https://images.huckmag.com/tco/images/Huck/L-to-R-Darina-AL-JOUNDI-as-Sara-Ali-EL-KAREEM-as-Boatman-and-Zainab-JODA-as-Reema.jpg?w=1920&q=75&auto=compress&format=jpg)
During the Gulf War in 1991, like most Iraqis in London, I was glued to the TV. I was watching the green anti-aircraft tracer fire in the night sky above Baghdad and the ‘smart’ bombs blowing up the bridges across the Tigris, the river which is the heart and soul of the city.
In all the hours of media coverage, I never saw or heard one ordinary Iraqi person on the screen. It was as if all the firepower was falling on no-one, as if the country, where I had deep roots, and all the people in it, was being erased off the face of the earth. I was in a state of shock. I forgot my name, how old I was, and the simplest of words in English which I have spoken all my life.
I am a London-based filmmaker of Iraqi origin. My response was to make a film of interviews with a wide variety of Iraqi women living in exile in London at that time, interspersed with archive footage. In the end, the film, Iraqi Women, Voices From Exile was a story of the Iraqi state and its people from the 1920s until 1991, told through the experiences of women.
![](https://images.huckmag.com/tco/images/Huck/Zainab-JODA-as-Reema-edited.jpg?w=1920&q=75&auto=compress&format=jpg)
I realised then that making in the face of ‘unmaking’ was a form of resistance. Excluding the voices of those who were on the receiving end of the violence made the killing more acceptable to people in the countries waging the war. In the UK, for example, people were not given a chance to see those who were being killed and displaced in their names as other human beings, just like themselves.
For years, as far as the Western media was concerned, Iraq was just Saddam Hussein. There was little sense of who the Iraqi people were or their culture and history. Iraqi civilians were erased from the Western media during the Gulf War through to the 2003 US-led invasion of the country and its aftermath.
What you never saw or heard were stories of individual people and communities, their aspirations, fears, daily struggles, their sense of humour in the face of destruction, their resilience, their courage, and their solidarity with one another.
![](https://images.huckmag.com/tco/images/Huck/L-to-R-Basim-HAJAR-as-Kamal-and-Labwa-ARAB-as-Mona.jpg?w=1920&q=75&auto=compress&format=jpg)
“No, we cannot relate to them if we don’t hear their voices and their stories.”
![](https://images.huckmag.com/tco/images/Huck/director-with-Suzanne-Monem-Saras-mother.jpeg?w=1920&q=75&auto=compress&format=jpg)
The cost of sidelining all this is that people become generalised ‘victims’. But the question is who are these people? Are we like them in some ways? Can we relate to their lives? What would I do in their place? No, we cannot relate to them if we don’t hear their voices and their stories. They are just ‘others’ of some sort.
It was these concerns that made me decide to make my recent fiction feature film, Our River… Our Sky as an ensemble of intersecting individual personal stories unfolding in Baghdad over the last week of 2006, a time of extreme sectarian violence.
My aim was not to focus on the violence on the streets, but rather to engage audiences in the everyday lives of my characters as they negotiate a difficult time of violence and social disintegration.
All the characters in the film are civilians: families, men, women, young people, and children. How do they manage to renew a fragile sense of hope every morning, when the world around them and inside them is shattering? How do parents protect their children? What do they tell them? How do they resist the damage all around and inside them? By telling jokes? Singing songs? Falling in love?
I’ve been surprised by and very grateful to Our River… Our Sky audiences who have said in many discussions after screenings, that they have found themselves thinking: ‘What would I have done if I were in their shoes?’
Sometimes I think of myself as a person who lives on a bridge; I have a view of both sides of the river and my job, as a filmmaker, is to make a connection between people on the two sides, so they can see each other as human beings like themselves – dealing with many of the same problems.
I imagine I will carry on making films about and in the Middle East, although not exclusively so. What will always be important to me is to represent the perspectives and voices of those who are usually sidelined, especially women and young people, who are such a large percentage of the population in the Middle East.
Whether the Western media, which these days often seems to be towing the official government line, will begin to represent the perspectives and voices of civilians in the Middle East, in a balanced way, is an open question. This is something I hope for, but I know it is unlikely, especially in the current conditions. I’m not holding my breath.
Our River.. Our Sky is out now in UK cinemas.
Enjoyed this article? Follow Huck on Twitter and Instagram.
Support stories like this by becoming a member of Club Huck.
Latest on Huck
![Autism cannot be cured — stop trying](https://images.huckmag.com/tco/images/Huck/shutterstock_2322534063.jpg?w=1920&q=75&auto=compress&format=jpg)
Autism cannot be cured — stop trying
A questionable study into the ‘reversal’ of autism does nothing but reinforce damaging stereotypes and harm, argues autistic author Jodie Hare.
Written by: Jodie Hare
![Bristol Photo Festival returns for second edition](https://images.huckmag.com/tco/images/Huck/Hashem-Shakeri-from-the-series-_Staring-into-the-Abyss_.-%C2%A9-Hashem-Shakeri.jpg?w=1920&q=75&auto=compress&format=jpg)
Bristol Photo Festival returns for second edition
After the success of it’s inaugural run, the festival returns this autumn with exhibitions, education and community programmes exploring a world in constant motion through still image.
Written by: Ben Smoke
![Documenting the life of a New York gang leader paralysed by gun violence](https://images.huckmag.com/tco/images/Huck/web-Eyanna-has-always-been-Maliks-primary-caregiver.jpg?w=1920&q=75&auto=compress&format=jpg)
Documenting the life of a New York gang leader paralysed by gun violence
New photobook ‘Say Less’ is a complex yet humanising look into a life wrecked by gun violence and organised crime.
Written by: Isaac Muk
![The woman who defined 80s Hip Hop photography](https://images.huckmag.com/tco/images/Huck/7_ULTRAMAGNETIC-MCS_NYC-1990.jpg?w=1920&q=75&auto=compress&format=jpg)
The woman who defined 80s Hip Hop photography
A new exhibition brings together Janette Beckman’s visionary and boundary pushing images of an era of cultural change and moral panic.
Written by: Miss Rosen
![In photos: the dogs of Dogtown](https://images.huckmag.com/tco/images/Huck/saguy_dogtown_02_RGB.jpg?w=1920&q=75&auto=compress&format=jpg)
In photos: the dogs of Dogtown
A new photobook documents Venice Beach’s four legged friends and their colourful cast of owners.
Written by: Isaac Muk
![Inside the battle to stop coal](https://images.huckmag.com/tco/images/Huck/DSC00173.jpg?w=1920&q=75&auto=compress&format=jpg)
Inside the battle to stop coal
As the legal challenge against Britain’s first deep coal mine in 30 years reaches the High court, we talk to activists at the centre of the fight to stop it.
Written by: Ben Smoke