The pioneering Black artists who revitalised photography

The pioneering Black artists who revitalised photography
The world‘s a stage — Leading art critic Robert Storr reflects on the photographers – from Seydou Keïta, to Malick Sidibé, to Carrie Mae Weems – who helped to transform and redefine the medium.

If “seeing is believing,” photography can be a slippery slope, falling into a curious space between art and evidence. Our fixation on photography as a form of truth can be attributed to “a desire for a representation that doesn’t lie,” says Robert Storr, author of the new book Writings on Art 2006-2021 (Heni).

“People don’t realise that the truth they’re looking for probably doesn’t exist in the first place,” he explains. “But if they do, somebody constructed that ‘truth’ from bits and pieces of reality of what one could experience directly.”

Storr cites Henri Cartier-Bresson’s “decisive moment” as one of the most enduring myths of photography. “There was this idea that the camera could capture the essence of reality and the photographer had to wait for that moment to present itself,” he says. 

Seydou Keïta, Untitled (Man with Flower), 1959

“The truth is, Cartier-Bresson took a lot of photographs that were close but not exact – so it’s not like he had some mythical ability to divine when that moment would happen.” 

Photography is littered with fictions and fabrications, many of them imposed by the cultural biases of artists and institutions themselves. Invented in the mid-nineteenth century, the camera became a tool of European imperialists as they colonised the globe. 

As nations achieved independence, photography became a tool of liberation in the hands of the people. For photographers Seydou Keïta and Malick Sidibé working in post-colonial Mali, the portrait became a means to express identity, agency, and self-determination. 

Seydou Keïta, Untitled, 1952-55

Carrie Mae Weems, Dad and Son-Son, 1978-84

“To see and capture individuality – as distinct from making a photographic case for ‘individualism’, an inherently ideological project that immediately trips on cultural differences between East and West, North and South – was Keïta’s extraordinary and sustaining gift,” Storr writes in the book.

Sidibé shared this gift in his extraordinary record of youth culture, defining itself in both his studio portraits and documentary photographs. “Sidibé found theatrical presence in ordinary people because they knew how to show up, dressed in their Sunday best,” says Storr.

While Keïta and Sidibé capture people living as though all the world were a stage, African-American artist Carrie Mae Weems transforms the photograph into a work of performance art.

Seydou Keïta, Untitled, 1956-57

Malick Sidibé, Chaussettes noires Party, 14 February 1964

“She’s an actress and uses her presence as an anchor to play a role,” Storr says. “Carrie Mae is an essentialised African-American woman representing all the things that can possibly mean in situations that are keyed to the presence or absence of Black women.”

In being both photographer and subject, Weems uses the camera to explore the construction of archetypes and myths at the intersection of gender and race. “She is photographing things as she sees them for people as she knows them, but is not trying to create a universal experience,” says Storr.

Occupying the space of both photographer and subject, Weems reminds us that images are constructions designed to convey feelings and ideas. They can centre or marginalise, embrace or exploit, render or erase individuals and histories alike. The photograph is evidence – perhaps less of what it shows than of the beliefs and intentions of the artist making it.

Malick Sidibé, James Brown Fans, 1965.

Malick Sidibé, Young Man with Bell Bottoms, Bag and Watch, 1977.

Follow Miss Rosen on Twitter. 

Enjoyed this article? Like Huck on Facebook or follow us on Twitter and Instagram

 

Latest on Huck

“Struggle helps people come together”: Sharon Van Etten & The Attachment Theory
Music

“Struggle helps people come together”: Sharon Van Etten & The Attachment Theory

Huck’s February interview — To hear more about the release of the indie darling’s first collaborative album, we caught up with her and Devra Hoff to hear about the record, motherhood in music and why the ’80s are back,

Written by: Isaac Muk

Nxdia: “Poems became an escape for me”
Music

Nxdia: “Poems became an escape for me”

What Made Me — In this series, we ask artists and rebels about the forces and experiences that shaped who they are. Today, it’s Egyptian-British alt-pop shapeshifter Nxdia.

Written by: Nxdia

Kathy Shorr’s splashy portraits inside limousines
Culture

Kathy Shorr’s splashy portraits inside limousines

The Ride of a Lifetime — Wanting to marry a love of cars and photography, Kathy Shorr worked as a limousine driver in the ’80s to use as a studio on wheels. Her new photobook explores her archive.

Written by: Miss Rosen

Lewd tales of live sex shows in ’80s Times Square
Culture

Lewd tales of live sex shows in ’80s Times Square

Peep Man — Before its LED-beaming modern refresh, the Manhattan plaza was a hotbed for seedy transgression. A new memoir revisits its red light district heyday.

Written by: Miss Rosen

In a world of noise, IC3PEAK are finding radicality in the quiet
Music

In a world of noise, IC3PEAK are finding radicality in the quiet

Coming Home — Having once been held up as a symbol of Russian youth activism and rebellion, the experimental duo are now living in exile. Their latest album explores their new reality.

Written by: Isaac Muk

Are we steamrolling towards the apocalypse?
Culture

Are we steamrolling towards the apocalypse?

One second closer to midnight — While the rolling news cycle, intensifying climate crisis and rapidly advancing technology can make it feel as if the end days are upon us, newsletter columnist Emma Garland remembers that things have always been terrible, and that is a natural part of human life.

Written by: Emma Garland

Sign up to our newsletter

Issue 81: The more than a game issue

Buy it now