Unravelling one of Iceland’s biggest murder mysteries
- Text by Jacob Charles Wilson
- Photography by Jack Latham

Violent crime is rare in Iceland, an island nation so small that it operates more like a town. Everyone knows everyone else, so when events do occur rumours and hearsay spread quickly.
In 1974, two men, Guðmundur and Geirfinnur, disappeared. Despite no known connection, and disappearing more than 10 months apart, the police decided to treat these incidents as a single murder case. Though no bodies, witnesses, or motives were produced, six young suspects were arrested, drugged, and tortured in solitary confinement before being forced to sign confessions.
Photographer Jack Latham became interested in the case while researching the oral narrative cultures of Scandinavia. Between 2014 and 2016, he started investigating the case files to understand how people could be made to doubt their own innocence. Latham is now showing his work at the Royal Photographic Society in Bristol, and publishing the second edition of his award-winning photobook Sugar Paper Theories, which includes a new foreword by Erla Bolladóttir, convicted of perjury for implicating her boyfriend and three friends in the case.

Keflavik, 16.02.77. Courtesy of the National Archives of Iceland
“The crux of the whole case is that the police fabricated a motive where they didn’t have one, and then spoon-fed that to vulnerable people to the point that they ended up believing it,” says Latham. For him, the fallibility of memory and the authority photographs hold over us are key to understanding the significant role imagery played in the case. In the absence of any other evidence, and assuming that their suspects had amnesia, the police attempted to jog their memories: “The police drove them out to where they thought they had murdered these people, and they had them recreate and photograph – almost play out – this murder. What’s remarkable is that these photos were then used as evidence.”
Latham sees an intimate link between the police’s construction of a narrative, and his own role in making a publication. “That idea of narrative storytelling and authority is something that I link to the act of photography; I sequence things and they become a narrative, and then you as a viewer are the prisoner in that analogy… You find yourself kind of in a grey area when you look at these very factual documents and grisly text and case file photos, you kind of get lulled into a false sense of security in and believe that these are things happened.”
Sugar Paper Theories draws on original photos and case files, as well as Latham’s new pictures and those of amateur sleuths, some of whom have been derided as conspiracy theorists. The recently discovered prison diaries of Guðjón Skarphéðinsson, one of the convicted, provide a personal account of confusion at the whole affair, and the gradual loss of his own mind. Former policeman and psychologist Gísli Guðjónsson also offers expert testimony on False Memory Syndrome.

Untitled. Courtesy of the National Archives of Iceland

KristjaÌn #9, Courtesy of the National Archives of Iceland
Latham is attentive to the ethical concerns of this work, and true crime as a genre. “The victims of these cases become objects of our fascination, and actually in my series, there’s not a single photo that I made of any of the six accused people. I photographed things about them, whether that was Guðjón’s church or Erla’s pet goldfish – references to them – but I thought it important not to put these people in that situation.”
In Latham’s mind, this is still an open case, and he sees the exhibition as timely. Last year, while five of the accused were acquitted, Erla had her conviction upheld. He sees involving Erla in the project as a matter of justice: “there’s justice for five, but if there’s not justice for everybody that’s not true justice.”
“We wanted to make a statement of giving Erla free run to write whatever she wanted about her experiences,” he adds. “This is someone who has been historically disenfranchised and objectified by the media. Erla and I are very close, and I think this was the first time that a member of the ‘media’, treated her with respect and presented her with dignity.”
“After all of these years, she’s still wanting justice, and wanting her name cleared, and that’s not the most ridiculous thing to ask for.”

Church #2, 2015, from Sugar Paper Theories, Jack Latham
Learn more about Jack Latham’s work, and Sugar Paper Theories, on his official website.
Follow Jacob Charles Wilson on Twitter.
Enjoyed this article? Like Huck on Facebook or follow us on Twitter.
Latest on Huck
Meet the hair-raised radical women of Berlin’s noise punk scene
Powertool — In his new zine, George Nebieridze captures moments of loud rage and quiet intimacy within the German capital’s female-only bands, while exploring the intersections between music, community and anti-establishment politics.
Written by: Miss Rosen

Amid tensions in Eastern Europe, young Latvians are reviving their country’s folk rhythms
Spaces Between the Beats — The Baltic nation’s ancient melodies have long been a symbol of resistance, but as Russia’s war with Ukraine rages on, new generations of singers and dancers are taking them to the mainstream.
Written by: Jack Styler

Uwade: “I was determined to transcend popular opinion”
What Made Me — In this series, we ask artists and rebels about the about the forces and experiences that shaped who they are. Today, it’s Nigerian-born, South Carolina-raised indie-soul singer Uwade.
Written by: Uwade

Inside the obscured, closeted habitats of Britain’s exotic pets
“I have a few animals...” — For his new series, photographer Jonty Clark went behind closed doors to meet rare animal owners, finding ethical grey areas and close bonds.
Written by: Hannah Bentley

Frazer Clarke: “I had a hole in my leg, I’m very lucky to be alive”
Hard Feelings — For our interview column on masculinity and fatherhood, the Olympic boxing medallist speaks to Robert Kazandjian about hard graft, the fear and triumph of his first fight, and returning to the ring after being stabbed on a night out.
Written by: Robert Kazandjian

Remembering Holly Woodlawn, Andy Warhol muse and trans trailblazer
Love You Madly — A new book explores the actress’s rollercoaster life and story, who helped inspire Lou Reed’s ‘Walk on the Wild Side’.
Written by: Miss Rosen