In defence of Chappell Roan

Newsletter columnist Emma Garland takes on The Rise and Fall of a Midwest Princess and the changing nature of fame.

This col­umn first fea­tured in Huck’s cul­ture newslet­ter. Sign up here to make sure it lands in your inbox as soon as it lands.

Chap­pell Roan wasn’t meant for all this. Chap­pell Roan is meant to be a queer icon and alt pop girlie. She should be occu­py­ing the same cul­tur­al space that Car­ly Rae Jepsen did with Emo­tion in the mid-2010s; a left-field song­writer with a zeit­geist-cap­tur­ing body of work that wasn’t par­tic­u­lar­ly com­mer­cial­ly suc­cess­ful, but amassed a cult fol­low­ing that would become the foun­da­tion of her fame going forward.

That’s almost what The Rise and Fall of a Mid­west Princess did for Chap­pell Roan. Her 2023 debut was met with a mod­est amount of crit­i­cal acclaim and a hearty dose of petrol on the flames of an already thriv­ing – but firm­ly under­ground – grass­roots fan­dom. It didn’t have much of an impact on the charts at first, but that was hard­ly sur­pris­ing for a first album from a drag queen who writes 2000s scan­dal­ism-inspired songs about eat­ing pussy. In the last few months, though, that’s all changed.

It start­ed typ­i­cal­ly enough. A slot open­ing for Olivia Rodri­go on tour; a viral appear­ance on NPR’s Tiny Desk that rock­et­ed her Spo­ti­fy month­ly lis­ten­ers count and turned The Rise and Fall of a Mid­west Princess into a sleep­er hit; per­for­mances at Coachel­la, the Governor’s Ball, and a slew of late night talk shows that became a series of coro­na­tions for her reign over the con­tem­po­rary pop land­scape. This has been the stan­dard mode of the hype’ machine post-social media, expe­ri­enced by every­one from Bön Iver to Ethel Cain. More recent­ly, though, it’s been mal­func­tion­ing. The pace of hype is mas­sive­ly accel­er­at­ed while also being trans­mit­ted across a dan­ger­ous­ly broad scale, turn­ing bur­geon­ing fame into a Faus­t­ian bargain.

“The problem is that there’s no such thing as “a bit famous” anymore” Emma Garland

Chap­pell Roan is cur­rent­ly receiv­ing news cov­er­age that out-strips most inter­na­tion­al con­flicts. The last few weeks she’s been stuck on a rolling cycle of inter­views, sound­bites, back­lash­es and clar­i­fi­ca­tions, prompt­ing fur­ther back­lash­es and clar­i­fi­ca­tions. Her name has been hoovered up into every dom­i­nant con­ver­sa­tion of the moment, from the U.S. Pres­i­den­tial Elec­tion to Israel’s war on Pales­tine, and the increas­ing­ly obses­sive nature of music fan­doms. For an emerg­ing artist, this is not nor­mal. Chap­pell Roan isn’t hav­ing her Car­ly Rae Jepsen cir­ca Emo­tion arc now, she’s hav­ing her Car­ly Rae Jepsen cir­ca Call Me Maybe’ arc – a moment of sud­den, over­whelm­ing atten­tion that came crash­ing down while she was still wait­ing tables. Jepsen has been vocal about her strug­gles with fame over the years, find­ing the paparazzi intru­sive and the expo­sure jar­ring. But even the height of Jepsen-mania didn’t see the artist grilled on her vot­ing inten­tions and then strung up for weeks over her answer.

What makes things worse, per­haps, is the kind of artist Chap­pell Roan is. She is a mod­ern pop star oper­at­ing in a mod­ern ecosys­tem that was shaped, in part, by the suc­cess of Car­ly Rae Jepsen; one that sees artists signed to major labels with iden­ti­ties, aes­thet­ics, and grass­roots fan­doms already in place. They’re cre­at­ed by the cul­ture and scout­ed by the indus­try, rather than the oth­er way around. They aren’t pre-pack­aged the way pre­vi­ous gen­er­a­tions of pop stars would have been, which makes for more inter­est­ing and diverse music but has its draw­backs for the artists per­son­al­ly. They’re being thrust into the same ech­e­lons of star­dom as Brit­ney Spears or Christi­na Aguil­era, but with­out the mega-sales or rel­a­tive insu­la­tion from the out­side world that came with old school Dis­ney kid fame. Rather, Roan, along with the rest of her gen­er­a­tion, appeals pre­cise­ly because she’s so acces­si­ble. They have com­mu­ni­ty-based rela­tion­ships with their fans, and speak out about caus­es close to their hearts. They seem like ordi­nary women, at home in front of small­er audi­ences,” Kate Moss­man wrote in the New States­man last week. The obses­sive behav­iour they inspire – tick­ets to Roan’s Brix­ton gig were fetch­ing £400 – says far more about the audi­ence than the music itself.”

Last month, Roan rebuked enti­tled’ fans for demand­ing pho­tos with her in pub­lic or track­ing down per­son­al infor­ma­tion, like where her par­ents live or her sis­ter works. It’s a com­mon com­plaint of fame in the 2020s – Phoebe Bridgers, Pete David­son and Doja Cat, have expressed sim­i­lar frus­tra­tions in recent years. How­ev­er, Roan’s barbed reac­tion to the spot­light has led to crit­i­cisms of its own. One viral tweet alleged that Roan is not built for fame” after she told the paparazzi to shut the fuck up” at the VMAs. It actu­al­ly wasn’t a paparazzi who was yelling at her, it was some­one else yelling at the paparazzi, but had it been a paparazzi she would have been well with­in her right to say some­thing. We have an infi­nite sup­ply of retroac­tive appre­ci­a­tion for fig­ures like Court­ney Love, Fiona Apple and Amy Wine­house, who held their own against the more intru­sive aspects of the media in the 90s and 2000s to their own detri­ment in moments that are now con­sid­ered leg­endary,” but when it hap­pens in front of us in real time it’s seen as ungrate­ful. With the scars of Y2K’s tox­ic celebri­ty cul­ture vis­i­ble on every­one who endured it, from Janet Jack­son to Paris Hilton, we still expect pop stars to be compliant.

A part of the prob­lem is that there’s no such thing as a bit famous” any­more. Chap­pell Roan is a rel­a­tive­ly new under­ground artist with a lot of anti-estab­lish­ment views. At any oth­er point in his­to­ry, she would not be front and cen­tre of the news cycle in broad­sheet news­pa­pers. She wouldn’t even be on their radar. She shouldn’t be any­where near the fed­er­al gov­ern­ment except to crit­i­cise it, but this sum­mer she was invit­ed to per­form at the White House’s Pride Cel­e­bra­tion. She turned it down, cit­ing the Biden-Har­ris administration’s fail­ure to defend queer rights against the hun­dreds of anti-LGBTQ+ bills tabled by Repub­li­cans, and their ongo­ing sup­port for Israel dur­ing the assault on Gaza. At the moment, though, she’s being raked over the coals for not endors­ing Kamala Har­ris in the upcom­ing elec­tion – a response that would be con­sid­ered stan­dard com­ing from an all-male band broad­ly iden­ti­fied as punk” but far less out­spo­ken than Roan has been.

The whole cir­cuit­ry of fan­dom has been dis­rupt­ed since the pan­dem­ic,” says jour­nal­ist Han­nah Ewens, writ­ing on the chang­ing nature of fan­dom in The Guardian. It used to be artist, fan and fan­dom in a Venn dia­gram, which held the shared world the artist and fan cre­at­ed togeth­er in the over­lap­ping cen­tre. Now it’s artist, fan, fan­dom and online audi­ence – and in the mid­dle, a neb­u­lous space that no longer feels like a shared secret, but a bat­tle­ground over the nar­ra­tive of that artist.”

Effec­tive­ly, the nature of fame in the 2020s is forc­ing Roan to address an audi­ence far beyond her nat­ur­al orbit. She’s an unortho­dox fig­ure embraced by a main­stream that is increas­ing­ly will­ing to cham­pi­on artists from LGBTQ+ spaces, but large­ly unwill­ing to accept the defi­ant views they might hold against the pow­er struc­tures sur­round­ing them – be it pol­i­tics, celebri­ty, or indeed their own fans.

Buy your copy of Huck 81 here.

Enjoyed this arti­cle? Fol­low Huck on Insta­gram.

Sup­port sto­ries like this by becom­ing a mem­ber of Club Huck.

You might like

Colourful collage of album covers and record sleeves on display in a gallery or museum setting, with glass panels on either side reflecting the vibrant arrangement.
Culture

Largest-Ever Display of UK AIDS Memorial Quilt Opens at Tate Modern

Grief Made Visible — Comprising hundreds of panels made by lovers, friends and chosen family, the UK AIDS Memorial Quilt returns in full for the first time since 1994 – a testament to grief, friendship and the ongoing fight against HIV stigma.

Written by: Ella Glossop

Children playing in a park fountain, black and white image
Culture

The carnival and community of New York’s block parties

Soul of the Summer — Since attending his first street party in Crown Heights two decades ago, photographer Anderson Zaca has spent his summers travelling across New York’s five boroughs, documenting over 300 in the process.

Written by: Miss Rosen

Black and white image of several people in suits, some with long hair and unconventional appearances, alongside a large ship or boat model. Text overlaid: "FREAKS AND FINANCES".
Culture

On Alexander Skarsgård’s trousers, The Rehearsal, and the importance of weirdos

Freaks and Finances — In the May edition of our monthly culture newsletter, columnist Emma Garland reflects on the Swedish actor’s Cannes look, Nathan Fielder’s wild ambition, and Jafaican.

Written by: Emma Garland

Grey industrial structure with arches, dog running in foreground.
Culture

Capturing life in the shadows of Canada’s largest oil refinery

The Cloud Factory — Growing up on the fringes of Saint John, New Brunswick, the Irving Oil Refinery was ever present for photographer Chris Donovan. His new photobook explores its lingering impacts on the city’s landscape and people.

Written by: Miss Rosen

Four persons - three women and one man - posing outdoors. The women are wearing elaborate clothing and jewellery.
Culture

Nostalgic photos of everyday life in ’70s San Francisco

A Fearless Eye — Having moved to the Bay Area in 1969, Barbara Ramos spent days wandering its streets, photographing its landscape and characters. In the process she captured a city in flux, as its burgeoning countercultural youth movement crossed with longtime residents.

Written by: Miss Rosen

Huck 79

We are all Mia Khalifa

How humour, therapy and community help Huck's latest cover star control her narrative.

Written by: Alya Mooro

Huck is supported by our readers, subscribers and Club Huck members. It is also made possible by sponsorship from:

Signup to our newsletter

Sign up to our newsletter to informed with the cutting edge of sport, music and counterculture, featuring personal takes on the state of media and pop culture from Emma Garland, former Digital Editor of Huck, exclusive interviews, recommendations and more.

Please wait...

Accessibility Settings

Text

Applies the Open Dyslexic font, designed to improve readability for individuals with dyslexia.

Applies a more readable font throughout the website, improving readability.

Underlines links throughout the website, making them easier to distinguish.

Adjusts the font size for improved readability.

Visuals

Reduces animations and disables autoplaying videos across the website, reducing distractions and improving focus.

Reduces the colour saturation throughout the website to create a more soothing visual experience.

Increases the contrast of elements on the website, making text and interface elements easier to distinguish.