Jason Appelbaum and Ai Weiwei are products of the surveillance era. Both have spoken out against the way their respective countries’ governments monitor citizens. Both have been politically persecuted as a consequence.
Ai Weiwei has been detained, questioned, and beaten by the police for his outspoken views. He can no longer leave China because they have taken away his passport. Jason Appelbaum has been advised not to return to the United States following several detentions at the airport for his involvement with WikiLeaks. But they refuse to be silenced.
Both familiar with being under constant surveillance, the two artists collaborated on an art project, “Panda to Panda,” where they stuffed toy pandas with shredded NSA documents and an SD card containing a backup of those documents.
The project explores what it means to be watched, and how watching the watcher engenders a shift in the power play of the situation; a zone of counter-surveillance. Appelbaum and Weiwei constantly filmed and photographed each other during the project in Weiwei’s studio in Beijing.
Laura Poitras, perhaps now best known for her Oscar-winning documentary Citizenfour on Edward Snowden, documented the encounter — adding her own layer to the hyper surveillance — in an op-doc (opinion documentary) for the New York Times.
The art project was commissioned by Rhizome and the New Museum in New York. Jason Appelbaum explains the story behind the project in the video below.
Latest on Huck
![Autism cannot be cured — stop trying](https://images.huckmag.com/tco/images/Huck/shutterstock_2322534063.jpg?w=1920&q=75&auto=compress&format=jpg)
Autism cannot be cured — stop trying
A questionable study into the ‘reversal’ of autism does nothing but reinforce damaging stereotypes and harm, argues autistic author Jodie Hare.
Written by: Jodie Hare
![Bristol Photo Festival returns for second edition](https://images.huckmag.com/tco/images/Huck/Hashem-Shakeri-from-the-series-_Staring-into-the-Abyss_.-%C2%A9-Hashem-Shakeri.jpg?w=1920&q=75&auto=compress&format=jpg)
Bristol Photo Festival returns for second edition
After the success of it’s inaugural run, the festival returns this autumn with exhibitions, education and community programmes exploring a world in constant motion through still image.
Written by: Ben Smoke
![Documenting the life of a New York gang leader paralysed by gun violence](https://images.huckmag.com/tco/images/Huck/web-Eyanna-has-always-been-Maliks-primary-caregiver.jpg?w=1920&q=75&auto=compress&format=jpg)
Documenting the life of a New York gang leader paralysed by gun violence
New photobook ‘Say Less’ is a complex yet humanising look into a life wrecked by gun violence and organised crime.
Written by: Isaac Muk
![The woman who defined 80s Hip Hop photography](https://images.huckmag.com/tco/images/Huck/7_ULTRAMAGNETIC-MCS_NYC-1990.jpg?w=1920&q=75&auto=compress&format=jpg)
The woman who defined 80s Hip Hop photography
A new exhibition brings together Janette Beckman’s visionary and boundary pushing images of an era of cultural change and moral panic.
Written by: Miss Rosen
![In photos: the dogs of Dogtown](https://images.huckmag.com/tco/images/Huck/saguy_dogtown_02_RGB.jpg?w=1920&q=75&auto=compress&format=jpg)
In photos: the dogs of Dogtown
A new photobook documents Venice Beach’s four legged friends and their colourful cast of owners.
Written by: Isaac Muk
![Inside the battle to stop coal](https://images.huckmag.com/tco/images/Huck/DSC00173.jpg?w=1920&q=75&auto=compress&format=jpg)
Inside the battle to stop coal
As the legal challenge against Britain’s first deep coal mine in 30 years reaches the High court, we talk to activists at the centre of the fight to stop it.
Written by: Ben Smoke