The puberty blocker ruling offers trans people hope

Sigh of relief — The overturning of the Bell v Tavistock ruling thanks to a trans-led appeal is a cause for celebration that gives hope of a pushback against entrenched English transphobia, writes Robin Craig.

On Friday (17 September), a ruling that had prevented trans adolescents under-16 from accessing puberty blockers was overturned. The Bell v Tavistock ruling, which had come into effect in December of last year via the High Court, specifically targeted the NHS England Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS) and decreed that under-16s were unable to meaningfully consent to reversible puberty blockers. The ruling hinged on Keira Bell, who brought the case after taking puberty blockers at 16, living as a transgender man and later seeking to ‘detransition’.

Medical intervention for trans adolescents was effectively cut off overnight – new referrals to the clinic were paused and pre-existing patients thrown into uncertainty about whether they would still be given their ongoing medication. Trans adolescents would have to individually apply for court approval to access puberty blockers, a cruel and inhumane process for acquiring potentially life-saving medication.

While The Good Law Project won a case establishing that parents can consent on behalf of their trans children in March this year, the original Bell v Tavistock ruling remained an enormous blow to trans rights in England. Trans adolescents without supportive parents were still unable to access puberty blockers as the ruling did not deem trans youth ‘Gillick competent’, a legal criteria that allows under-16s to consent to treatment independent of their parents.

Last week, the ruling was finally completely overturned after an intervention led by trans charity Gendered Intelligence alongside Brook, The Endocrine Society and Liberty, backed by the legal expertise of The Good Law Project. The original ruling was deemed a transgression of the Gillick competence test and the appeal stated GIDS had not broken the law by prescribing puberty blockers to trans adolescents. Medical treatment for trans youths in England can now resume as normal, subject to NHS England guidelines.

The successful appeal was, rightly, celebrated across social media by trans people and allies as a much-needed win amidst an increasingly hostile and transphobic landscape in the UK. The appeal is not only good news for trans adolescents seeking healthcare, but also a spark of hope for trans people in the UK that we can fight transphobia and win.

In recent years the fight for trans liberation in the UK has often felt like an uphill battle. In 2018 the public consultation for Gender Recognition Act (GRA) reform, which proposed easier and cheaper routes for trans people to change the gender on their birth certificates, was met with open hostility from multiple mainstream media outlets. One research paper found that in 2018 alone The Times published 323 articles largely critical of transgender rights and lives, averaging nearly one article per day. After two years of delay, the government scrapped most of the proposed reforms in 2020.

More recently, Tory equalities minister Kemi Badenoch has been criticised for calling trans women ‘men’ in a leaked audio recording, while Labour MP Rosie Duffield lashed out against GRA reform and referred to trans women as ‘male-bodied biological men’ on Twitter. In a 2020 study conducted by LGBT+ anti-violence charity GALOP, 93 per cent of trans respondents stated that they had experienced transphobia in the previous twelve months and 81 per cent reported they had experienced a transphobic hate crime. Meanwhile, a 2021 Freedom of Information request revealed the current wait time for an initial appointment at the UK’s leading NHS Gender Identity Clinic currently stands at 106 weeks, or just over two years. Trans life in the UK is still marked by inequality and violence, whether from the halls of parliament, transphobic street harassment, or medical neglect.

Amidst this, the success of the trans-led appeal against the Bell v Tavistock ruling comes as welcome good news that, I hope, signals a pushback against entrenched English transphobia. While true trans liberation cannot be achieved without abolishing capitalism, there are immediate actions which, if taken, would drastically improve trans life in the UK that we must continue fighting for. We must push for an informed consent model of trans healthcare where any trans adult can access hormone therapy with no psychiatric gatekeeping, in line with Australia and parts of the USA. We must also demand a radical overhaul of GIDS, ensuring they no longer pathologise trans youths and expand their services to see the thousands of young people waiting for a first appointment.

This work has already begun – gender services such as TransPlus in London, Indigo Gender in Manchester and CMAGIC in Merseyside are trialling holistic transition care outside of the traditional gender clinic model. In Scotland, the new policy coalition between Scottish Greens and SNP includes a complete reform of Scottish trans healthcare and the GRA. The repeal of the Bell v Tavistock ruling is another encouraging sign that significant trans healthcare reform is within our reach but we must keep pushing. 

The fight for trans liberation is not linear nor a guaranteed victory, and is reliant on trans people and cisgender allies working in coalition against those who would divide us. Overturning the Bell v Tavistock ruling is a cause for celebration and a brief moment of respite amidst often brutally transphobic conditions in the UK. We must, however, keep demanding radical trans healthcare reforms that depathologise and expand access to medical transition for both trans adults and adolescents alike. 

To support transgender children and adolescents, please consider donating to Gendered Intelligence.

Follow Robin Craig on Twitter.

Enjoyed this article? Like Huck on Facebook or follow us on Twitter.


You might like

A crowd of protesters holding placards and banners, including flags of Ireland, with "Defend the right to protest" and "Defend knee" written on them.
Activism

In photos: Hundreds gather outside court to protest Kneecap terror charge

‘Free Mo Charah’ — With drums, smoke and applause, protesters greeted the rapper outside court as he was released on unconditional bail.

Written by: Ella Glossop

Portrait of a bald man with glasses and a beard, set against a blurred background.
Activism

Misan Harriman: “The humanity I bear witness to is extraordinary”

Shoot the People — Following the premiere of a new film exploring the photographer’s work and driving forces, we caught up with him to chat about his rapid rise, shooting protests and the need for powerful documentarians in times of struggle.

Written by: Isaac Muk

Bus shelter display advertising Father's Day with orange and black text against an image of a man's face.
Activism

Campaigners hack UK bus ads on Father’s Day to demand Alaa Abd El-Fattah’s release

A father behind bars — Placing posters at bus stops around London, Leeds and Manchester, they called for greater action from foreign secretary David Lammy to reunite the British-Egyptian activist with his son and family.

Written by: Isaac Muk

Three smiling women wearing glamorous dresses and fur coats posing together.
Culture

The Getty Center’s first exclusively queer exhibition opens today

$3 Bill: Evidence of Queer Lives — Running until September, it features paintings, ephemera, video and photography to highlight LGBTQ+ histories, culture and people from 1900 to the present day.

Written by: Isaac Muk

Man singing at microphone on stage, wearing red shirt and tattoo on arm, playing electric guitar.
Activism

Green Day’s Billie Joe Armstrong tells ICE to “fuck off” in LA protest video

Saviors — The singer shared the post on Sunday, featuring the band’s recently released song ‘Fuck Off’ as its soundtrack.

Written by: Isaac Muk

Music

Jack Johnson

Letting It All Out — Jack Johnson’s latest record, Sleep Through The Static, is more powerful and thought provoking than his entire back catalogue put together. At its core, two themes stand out: war and the environment. HUCK pays a visit to Jack’s solar-powered Casa Verde, in Los Angeles, to speak about his new album, climate change, politics, family and the beauty of doing things your own way.

Written by: Tim Donnelly

Huck is supported by our readers, subscribers and Club Huck members. It is also made possible by sponsorship from:

Signup to our newsletter

Sign up to our newsletter to informed with the cutting edge of sport, music and counterculture, featuring personal takes on the state of media and pop culture from Emma Garland, former Digital Editor of Huck, exclusive interviews, recommendations and more.

Please wait...